1 / 6
From John's Pizzeria's website

From John's Pizzeria's website

John's Pizzeria

Pizza · Dyer

Closed

opens 3pm today

By phone

orders & questions

Call to order · (219) 322-8400

Want to order pickup from here?

John's Pizzeria isn’t taking online orders yet. Tell us you’d order, and we’ll email you the day they start.

One email when pickup opens. Unsubscribe anytime.

Feeding a crowd? Ask John's Pizzeria to quote for an event.
I ate here Add to my list

AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies

Closed · opens 3pm today · try the MAC & CHEESE · about $25 a person

What to order

from the menu

Pizza — food to try

4 on this menu
  1. Cheese pizza✓ On the menu

    The plainest pie is the honest test of the crust and sauce.

    Here it's “SUNDAYS Free 10” cheese pizza with purchase of an 18” one topping pizza.”.

  2. Deep dish✓ On the menu

    Chicago's own — a buttery crust with the sauce on top. Give it 35 minutes.

    Here it's “STUFFED MUSHROOMS”.

  3. Sausage pizza✓ On the menu

    The Midwest's default topping, crumbled fresh rather than sliced.

    Here it's “MEATBALLS (2) OR ITALIAN SAUSAGE LINK”.

  4. Garlic knots✓ On the menu

    Same dough, tied and buttered — the side to share while you wait.

    Here it's “THURSDAYS Free Cheesy Garlic Bread with purchase of a 12” one topping pizza.”.

Menu

from the website · 2026-09-02

Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.

Specials

Appetizers

Salads

Sandwiches

Pasta

Parmigiana Dinner

Dinners

Seafood

Chicken

Pizza

Beverages

Desserts

1209 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN, 46311

Directions
Closed· opens 3pm todayAll hours ▾
Wednesday (today)
3pm–9pm
Thursday
3pm–9pm
Friday
3pm–10pm
Saturday
3pm–10pm
Sunday
3pm–9pm
Monday
Closed
Tuesday
3pm–9pm

Hours from the restaurant's website — call ahead on holidays.

Website ↗

Popular restaurants nearby

Chicago
Claim it