Lexington Avenue
Sandwiches · New York
By phone
orders & questions
Menu
from the website · Sep 2, 2026Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
All-Day Breakfast
- NATALIE'S 100% ORANGE JUICE$5.00
- SILVER DOLLAR BUTTERMILK PANCAKESLight and fluffy mini pancakes (6) served with maple syrup and a dusting of powdered sugar$11.00
- DISCO FRIESCrispy French fries topped with rich gravy, melted mozzarella and two soft eggs$13.00
- AVOCADO TOASTToasted health bread layered with smashed avocado, fresh tomato, arugula, pickled red onions and two soft fried eggs$14.00
- BACON EGG & CHEESETwo fried eggs topped with smoked bacon and American cheese on a toasted bun$6.50
Burgers
- The Schnipper Burger Special*Includes fries and a soda
- Cheeseburger$18.00
- The Old FashionedDine-in only$18.50
- Schnippers Classic$21.00
- Hamburger*$10.00
- Cheeseburger*$10.50
- Bacon Cheeseburger*With thick-cut applewood smoked bacon$12.00
- The Schnipp*With double American cheese, lettuce, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce$11.00
- The Big Schnipp*A monster 10 oz double cheeseburger with lettuce, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce$17.00
- Schnipper's Classic*Our special cheese blend, caramelized onions, thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, baby arugula, Schnipper sauce$13.50
- The Old Fashioned*Dine-in onlyExtra juicy with double American cheese, griddled onions, and classic pink sauce$11.00
- The (Not So) Impossible Burger*NY State white cheddar, caramelized onions, lettuce, plum tomato, BBQ sauce, and Schnipper sauce on an Orwasher’s seeded roll$15.50
- The Turkey Burger*Freshly ground with smashed avocado, pickled red onions, plum tomatoes, and creamy brown mustard relish on an Orwasher’s whole wheat roll$14.00
- The Veggie BoyveganVegetable patty with guacamole, plum tomato, red onion, and spicy radish sprouts on an Orwasher’s whole wheat roll$13.00
Chicken Fingers & Fries
Sauces
Sandwiches
- Bros. Done Right ClubGrilled chicken, thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, guacamole, greens, red onion, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce, toasted ciabatta$14.50
- Not Just Any Buffalo ChickenCrispy chicken, spicy buffalo sauce, kale and cabbage slaw, Danish blue cheese, Schnipper sauce, seeded roll$12.50
- Chicken Filet on a Really Good Seeded RollCrispy or grilled. With Allen’s local pickles and Schnipper sauce$11.50
- Grilled 4 CheeseOur gooey 4 cheese blend on crispy griddled sourdough$13.50
- A Lotta Bacon BLTLots of thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, greens, plum tomatoes, mayo, toasted sourdough bread$13.50
- Sweet Heat Crispy ChickenCrispy chicken with lettuce, sweet cherry peppers and mayo on a seeded bun$12.50
- Grilled Chicken and BrieGrilled chicken, French brie, plum tomato, baby arugula, red onion, herb mayo, toasted ciabatta$14.50
- Schnipper's Crispy ChickenCrispy chicken, sharp white cheddar, caramelized onions, BBQ sauce, greens, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce, toasted ciabatta$14.50
- Fresh Veggie and Goat CheeseAvocado, baby arugula, plum tomatoes, radish sprouts, and vinaigrette on toasted whole wheat ciabatta$13.50
- Schnipper's Tuna MeltSolid white albacore tuna salad with New York State white cheddar cheese on thick sliced Orwasher's sourdough$14.50
Fries & Sides
- House Fries$5.25
- Cheese FriesHouse-made cheese sauce$6.25
- Sloppy FriesSloppy joe, cheddar cheese, house-made cheese sauce$11.50
- Sweet Potato FriesWith maple dipping sauce$6.25
- Thick Cut Onion RingsWith chipotle ranch$9.00
- Schnipper's SlawKale and cabbage$5.75
- Charred BroccoliWith lemon and chiles$5.75
- Baby ArugulaWith grape tomatoes, Grana Padana, and house vinaigrette$5.75
- Grilled Fresh Corn EsquitesMexican street corn off the cob$5.75
- Homemade ChipsFried extra crispy$4.75
- Mac & JoeSuper Creamy Mac and Cheese$9.75
- Jon's Famous Sloppy Joe Sandwich$11.50
- Mac and JoeHalf mac and cheese, half sloppy joe. No bun!$12.50
Salads & Bowls
- Fresh From The MarketMixed greens, fresh beets, grilled sweet corn, avocado, toasted pumpkin seeds, grape tomatoes, Grana Padana, radish, ciabatta croutons, house vinaigrette$13.50
- Mama's MediterraneanMixed greens, feta cheese, grape tomatoes, Kalamata olives, charred broccoli, pickled red onion, chickpeas, hot cherry peppers, ciabatta croutons, house vinaigrette$13.50
- South by SouthwestMixed greens, grilled sweet corn, grape tomatoes, green and red bell peppers, cotija cheese, pickled jalapenos, chile-dusted tortilla strips, scallions, chipotle ranch dressing$13.50
- The Proper CobbMixed greens, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, Danish blue cheese, grape tomatoes, ciabatta croutons, blue cheese dressing$13.50
- Caesar #2Romaine, Grana Padana, pickled red onion, grape tomatoes, ciabatta croutons, Caesar dressing$12.50
- Fresh Beet and Goat CheeseMixed greens, beets, goat cheese, dried cranberries, scallions, toasted walnuts, ciabatta croutons, vinaigrette$13.50
- A Great Grain BowlGrilled or crispy chicken, organic Italian farro, charred broccoli, grilled corn esquites, baby arugula, grape tomatoes, guacamole, pickled red onions, house vinaigrette (on the side)$16.50
Hot Dogs
Shakes & Floats
- MilkshakesHandcrafted using Gifford's ice cream. Choose from: Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla, Cookies & Cream, Salted Caramel, Black & White, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Honey Vanilla, Neapolitan, Chocolate Malt$10.00
- Ice Cream FloatsRoot Beer: root beer with vanilla ice cream Purple Cow: grape soda with vanilla ice cream Orange Creamsicle: orange soda with vanilla ice cream$9.50
Burger Platters
- Classic PlatterHamburgers, Cheeseburgers$15.00
- Mixed PlatterHamburgers, Cheeseburgers, Turkey Burgers, and Veggie Burgers$15.50
- Schnipper's Specialty PlatterA mix of our favorite hamburgers, cheeseburgers, bacon cheeseburgers, Schnipper's Classic, and The Old Fashioned (Impossible burger +$3 per person)$17.00
Catering Sandwich Platters
- Bros. Done Right ClubGrilled chicken, thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, guacamole, greens, red onion, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce on ciabatta$18.75
- A Lotta Bacon BLTLots of thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, greens, plum tomatoes, mayo on sourdough$18.75
- Grilled Chicken and BrieGrilled chicken, French brie, plum tomatoes, baby arugula, red onion, herb mayo on ciabatta$18.75
- Schnipper's Tuna SaladSolid white albacore tuna salad, tomatoes, lettuce on ciabatta$18.75
- Veggie and Goat CheeseAvocado, baby arugula, plum tomatoes, radish sprouts, goat cheese and vinaigrette on whole wheat$18.75
- Schnipper's Crispy ChickenCrispy chicken, sharp white cheddar, caramelized onions, BBQ sauce, greens, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce on ciabatta$18.75
- Not Just Any Buffalo ChickenCrispy chicken, spicy buffalo sauce, kale and cabbage slaw, Danish blue cheese, Schnipper sauce on ciabatta$18.75
- Sweet Heat Crispy Chicken SandwichSlightly sweet and LOTS of heat with lettuce, sweet cherry peppers, and mayo on a seeded bun$18.75
- Chicken Filet on a Really Good Seeded RollCrispy or grilled chicken with Allen's local pickles and Schnipper sauce$18.75
Catering Hot Dogs & Sides
- Simple Grilled Dog (per person)Crispy grilled dogs served with ketchup, mustard, relish, and onion$10.00
- Cheese Dog (per person)Served with house-made sauce$11.00
- Sloppy Dog (per person)Served with sloppy joe and cheddar cheese$12.00
- French Fries (serves 8-10)$65.00
- Sweet Potato Fries (serves 8-10)With maple dipping sauce$75.00
- Onion Rings with Chipotle Ranch (serves 6-8)$85.00
- Homemade Potato Chips (serves 12-16)$75.00
- Kale and Cabbage Slaw (serves 6-10)$75.00
- Homemade Macaroni Salad (serves 6-10)$75.00
Catering Chicken Fingers
Catering Salads
- Fresh From The Market (catering)Mixed greens, fresh beets, grilled sweet corn, avocado, toasted pumpkin seeds, grape tomatoes, Grana Padano, radish, ciabatta croutons, house vinaigrette$160.00
- Mama's Mediterranean (catering)Mixed greens, feta cheese, grape tomatoes, Kalamata olives, charred broccoli, pickled red onion, chickpeas, hot cherry peppers, ciabatta croutons, house vinaigrette$160.00
- South by Southwest (catering)Mixed greens, grilled sweet corn, grape tomatoes, green and red bell peppers, cotija cheese, pickled jalapenos, chile dusted tortilla strips, scallions, chipotle ranch dressing$160.00
- The Proper Cobb (catering)Mixed greens, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, hard boiled egg, Danish blue cheese, grape tomatoes, ciabatta croutons, blue cheese dressing$160.00
- Caesar #2 (catering)Romaine, Grana Padano, pickled red onion, grape tomatoes, ciabatta croutons, Caesar dressing$160.00
- Fresh Beet & Goat Cheese (catering)Mixed greens, beets, goat cheese, dried cranberries, toasted walnuts, ciabatta croutons, house vinaigrette$160.00
Catering Mac & Joe and Sloppy Joe
Shakes & Desserts (Catering)
- Milkshakes (catering)Handcrafted using Gifford’s ice cream. Choose from: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, cookies & cream, black & white, and salted caramel$11.00
- Pastries (assortment, serves 8-12)A delicious assortment of Brownies, Cookies, and Bars. Please inquire for selection$75.00
- Fresh Seasonal Fruit Salad (serves 8-12)$90.00
Beverages (Catering)
Breakfast Specials
- DISCO EGGSCrispy French fries topped with rich gravy, melted mozzarella and two soft eggs
- SILVER DOLLAR BUTTERMILK PANCAKESLight and fluffy mini pancakes (6) served with maple syrup and a dusting of powdered sugar. Add chocolate chips or blueberries
- BACON EGG & CHEESETwo fried eggs topped with smoked bacon, and American cheese on a toasted
- Avocado ToastToasted health bread layered with smashed avocado, fresh tomato, arugula, pickled red onions and two soft fried eggs
Burger Special
Sandwich Special
Soups
- Cold Chunky GazpachoOur refreshing, zesty summer gazpacho is made chunky style and loaded with fresh vegetables and cilantro, from our sister restaurant on the Upper East Side.
- CHICKEN VEGETABLEClassic chicken soup with white meat chicken and plenty of vegetables from our sister restaurant on the Upper East Side. Optional alphabet pasta.
- TOMATO CHEDDARA smooth, creamy purée of tomatoes blended with extra-sharp cheddar cheese, from our sister restaurant on the Upper East Side.
Milkshake Specials
- ORANGE CREAMSICLE SHAKEVanilla ice cream blended with orange sherbet and fresh orange juice
- THE SCHMIGA SHAKECreamy vanilla ice cream blended with ripe banana and rich caramel, finished with whipped cream and a caramel drizzle, in collaboration with the new musical Schmigadoon, playing next door at the Nederlander Theater
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the Schnipper's Classic* · about $14 a person
What to order
from the menuSchnipper's Classic*
Our special cheese blend, caramelized onions, thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, baby arugula, Schnipper sauce
Burgers$13.50
Schnipper's Specialty Platter
A mix of our favorite hamburgers, cheeseburgers, bacon cheeseburgers, Schnipper's Classic, and The Old Fashioned (Impossible burger +$3 per person)
Burger Platters$17
Classic Platter
Hamburgers, Cheeseburgers
Burger Platters$15
Bros. Done Right Club
Grilled chicken, thick-cut applewood smoked bacon, guacamole, greens, red onion, plum tomatoes, Schnipper sauce, toasted ciabatta
Sandwiches$14.50
The Schnipper Burger Special*
Includes fries and a soda
Burgers
Schnippers Classic
Burgers$21
Sandwiches — food to try
1 on this menuTurkey club✓ On the menu · $14.50
Three slices, toasted, stacked. Boring done well is the point.
Here it's “Bros. Done Right Club”.
New York, NY, 10022
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedL&B Spumoni Gardens
Italian
4.6★ (11,500+)·$$

Hard Rock Cafe New York
American
4.4★ (25,000+)·1.1 mi

Koren Bbq
Korean
4.7★ (19,000+)·1.1 mi

Veselka
Ukrainian
4.6★ (7,500+)·2.2 mi

Shake Shack
Burger
4.5★ (7,500+)·1.5 mi

Ippudo
Japanese
4.4★ (5,500+)·2.2 mi

Momofuku Noodle Bar
Noodles
4.5★ (5,000+)·2.1 mi

Bierhaus NYC
German
4.3★ (3,500+)·0.4 mi

Taco Bell
Taco
4.0★ (2,500+)·1.5 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →