Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels
Bagels · Brooklyn
By phone
orders & questions
Menu
from the website · Sep 2, 2026Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Sandwich with A Schmear
- Bagel with Butter$4.49
- Bagel with Plain Cream Cheese$6.99
- Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese$7.49
- Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese$9.49
- Bagel with Veggy Cream Cheese$8.99
- Bagel with Horseradish Cream Cheese$8.49
- Bagel with Vegan Cream Cheese$8.49
- Bagel with Vegan Scallion Cream CheeseHouse whipped, fresh scallion with the all natural tofu flavor on your bagel, bialy, or rye bread of your choice$8.99
- Sichuan Chili Crisp Cream Cheese on A Bagel or BialyWe blend Laoganma, (angry lady sauce aka spicy chili crisp) with cream cheese. It's loaded with chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, Sichuan peppercorns, and msg. IT. IS. AWESOME.$9.49
- Butter and Jelly on A Bagel or Bialy SandwichI Mean.$4.99
- Plain Cream Cheese and Jelly on A Bagel or Bialy SandwichIt's a mood thing. Sometimes you just in the mood for this. Choice of raspberry or apricot.$7.49
- Jalapeno Cream Cheese on A Bagel or Bialy SandwichCream cheese mixed with diced fresh jalapenos (seeds and all so it is pretty spicy) served on a bagel or bialy.$7.49
- Jalapeño Garlic Cream Cheese on A Bagel or Bialy$7.49
- Bacon Cheddar Cream Cheese on a Bagel or Bialy$8.99
- Olive Cream Cheese on a Bagel or Bialy$7.49
Salad Spread Sandwiches
- Smoked Whitefish Salad with Cucumber & Celery On a BreadOur smoky whitefish salad works beautifully with the gentle sweetness of our chewy bagels. It is also perfect on a bialy.$16.49
- Baked Salmon Salad On a BreadOur baked salmon salad is RICH, and if your are absolutely fah-mished, then having it on a bagel or bialy will totally satisfy you!$16.49
- Seriously Great Tuna Salad On a BreadWe're not joking. Our tuna salad is seriously great. Have a tuna sandwich. When was the lost time you just had a tuna sandwich. Go for it. It's a classic done right.$13.99
- Egg Salad with Cornichons On a BreadOur egg salad has little disks of cornichons (pickled gherkins) in it. Served on your choice of bread.$12.99
- Chicken Salad with Pecans, Grapes & Celery On a BreadWe take extra care to gently poach our chicken for this salad, ensuring that each cube of chicken is moist and juicy! Served on your choice of bread. (yeah, we said moist... sorry, not sorry)$13.99
- Chopped Chicken Liver On BreadWe hand-chop our chicken livers and gently fold them with duck fat, hard-cooked eggs, and sautéed onions. Cognac rounds it out to make it the perfect chopped liver. Served on your choice of bread.$15.99
- Pickled Herring Salad On a BreadOur pickled herring salad is brown. It isn't pretty. But it's SO TASTY! It's great with some butter and thinly-sliced red onion. Served on your choice bread.$13.99
Smoked Fish Sandwiches
- Member of The TribeGaspe nova, scallion or plain cream cheese, served on a bagel or bialy.$18.99
- The TurboffBaked salmon salad, hand-sliced Eastern Gaspe Nova, horseradish cream cheese, tomatoes, thinly-sliced red onions, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.$20.99
- Brooklyn NativeRich and silky kippered salmon, apple horseradish sauce, plain cream cheese, and pickled herring salad. Served on your choice of bread.$20.99
- The Great GatsbyPastrami-smoked salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese, and thinly sliced red onion. We invented the sandwich on seeded rye. We suggest it on seeded rye. But, feel free to make a different bread choice. It's your sandwich. But, we're right. Just sayin'!$19.99
- The NewhouseHand-sliced wild Alaskan sable, scallion cream cheese, and tomatoes. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.$20.99
- The ClementineHouse-cured gravlax, butter, thinly-sliced red onion, tomatoes, capers, and lemon juice. We suggest this sandwich on a toasted bialy, but we're happy to serve it on your bread of choice.$20.49
Breakfast Sandwiches
- Egg Sandwich$8.99
- Egg & Cheese Sandwich$9.99
- Bacon & Egg Sandwich$9.99
- Sausage & Egg Sandwich$9.99
- Ham & Egg Sandwich$9.99
- Jersey Pork Roll & Egg SandwichSevered on a plain roll unless otherwise requested$11.49
- Pastrami & Egg SandwichServed on seeded rye bread unless otherwise requested$12.99
- Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich$10.99
- Sausage, Egg & Cheese Sandwich$10.99
- Ham, Egg & Cheese Sandwich$10.99
- Jersey Pork Roll Egg & Cheese SandwichServed on a plain roll unless otherwise requested$12.49
- Pastrami, Egg, & CheeseServed on seeded rye bread unless otherwise requested$13.99
- Cream Cheese & Bacon SandwichChoose your cream cheese$9.49
- Grilled Cheese on Plain Rye SandwichYour choice of cheese grilled on plain rye.$6.49
- BLTBacon, lettuce and tomato on your choice of bread with mayonnaise.$9.49
Shelsky's Lunch Sandwiches Our Way
- Shelsky's Roast Turkey SandwichOur homemade, thinly-sliced roasted turkey, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on your choice of bread.$20.99
- Shelsky's Hot Pastrami SandwichShelsky's thinly-sliced, super moist pastrami, served hot with brown deli mustard on your choice of Orwasher's Bakery rye or pumpernickel bread.$27.99
- Shelsky's Hot Corned Beef SandwichShelsky's thinly-sliced corned beef, served hot with brown deli mustard on your choice of Orwasher's rye or pumpernickel bread.$26.99
- Shelsky's Reuben SandwichA hefty pressed sandwich of Shelsky's thinly-sliced hot corned beef, riesling-braised sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. Served on your choice of Orwasher's Bakery rye or pumpernickel bread.$28.99
- Shelskys Roast Beef RollWe roast Dellapietra's beef rounds slowly to a beautifully rosy-pink medium-rare. We then thinly slice it and gently fold it onto an Orwasher's Bakery onion roll with butter, Dijon mustard, and crispy fried Chinese onions. It's definitely best on that roll, but we're happy to serve it on your choice of bread.$19.99
- Chopped Cheese SandwichChopped up hamburgers with melted american cheese, grilled onions, raw onions, lettuce, tomato, ketchup and mayonnaise pressed on a seeded hero.$15.49
Lunch Sandwiches Your Way
- Roast Beef Lunch SandwichHomemade roast beef on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
- Roast Turkey Lunch SandwichHomemade roasted dipaola turkey farm turkey on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
- Cooked Ham Lunch SandwichSchaller & Weber ham on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
- Black Forest Ham Lunch SandwichSchaller & Weber black forest ham on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
- Sliced Liverwurst Lunch SandwichSchaller & Weber braunschweiger liverwurst sliced and served on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
- Bologna Lunch SandwichSchaller & Weber bologna sliced and served on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.$11.99
Bagels, Bialys & Breads
- Plain Bagel3-day fermented, sourdough plain bagels, dense, chewy, just the right size.$1.99
- Sesame BagelOur plain bagels coated with sesame seeds and just a touch of pretzel salt.$1.99
- Poppy BagelOur plain bagels coated with poppy seeds.$1.99
- Everything BagelOur plain bagels coated with our own homemade everything topping.$1.99
- Onion BagelOur plain bagels coated with dried onion flakes.$1.99
- Garlic BagelOur plain bagels coated with crunchy dried garlic.$1.99
- Salt BagelOur plain bagels coated with pretzel salt.$1.99
- Cracked Pepper & Salt BagelOur plain bagels coated with lots of cracked pepper and pretzel salt. A bagel au poivre.$1.99
- Pumpernickel BagelA complex chewy bagel with rye flour, coffee and cocoa powder.$1.99
- Egg BagelNot your average egg bagel. Made with egg yolks, turmeric, annatto and indian sulfur salt.$1.99
- Cinnamon Raisin BagelNot as sweet as is often the case, our cinnamon raisin bagels are pretty perfect.$1.99
- Whole Wheat BagelA whole wheat bagel made whole wheat flour and a mash of rolled and steel cuts oats, hemp seed, flax seed and wheat germ topped with a germ mixture.$1.99
- Whole Wheat Everything BagelOur stunning whole wheat bagels topped with everything topping.$1.99
- Sichuan Peppercorn Bagel(numbing). our plain bagels with numbing zing of imported single plantation sichuan peppercorns mixed into the dough and topped with black and whites sesame seeds.$3.50
- Pretzel Bagel$3.50
- Garlic Bialy$3.00
- Plain (Onion) BialyThe lighter polish-jewish cousin of the bagel, not boiled topped with slowly-cooked onion confit.$3.00
- Gluten Free Plain$4.99
- Gluten Free Everything$4.99
- Gluten Free Sesame$4.99
- Mixed Baker's DozenChoice of any mixture of bagels and or bialys. If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the special instructions.$25.00
- Kaiser RollMazzola kaiser rolls, simple, classic.$1.00
- Onion RollOrwasher's bakery onion pocket with onions inside and out, a new york classic.$1.00
- Lard BreadMazzola bakery lard bread, a hero loaf with salami, cheese and lots of black pepper a carroll gardens italian classic.$9.00
- Seeded Hero RollClassic seeded hero roll from mazzola bakery.$3.00
Cream Cheeses
- Plain Cream Cheese$7.49/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy - the perfect spread for a bagel!$8.99
- Scallion Cream Cheese$7.99/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We mix it with a whole lot of freshly chopped scallions. It's the perfect spread for a bagel!$9.49
- Vegetable Cream Cheese$8.49/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. We then brunoise red, orange, and yellow bell peppers, and combine them with minced fresh garlic, to make some truly remarkable vegetable cream cheese.$9.99
- Horseradish Cream Cheese$11.99/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. One brave soul on our team, then puts on a pair of goggles and finely grates a whole bunch of horseradish root. That and a healthy pinch of ground white pepper get folded into the cream cheese. Not gonna lie, it's pretty awesome.$13.49
- Lox Cream Cheese$11.49/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Ground Nova is whipped into our cream cheese to make this appetizing shop and bagel store classic. As for me? I LOVE it on a poppy seed bagel. But that's me. You do you.$12.99
- Chili Crisp Cream CheeseDouble-whipped cream cheese with spicy chili crisp (ground dried chilies, soy nuts, fried onions, sichuan peppercorns and msg). Priced by the half pound.$10.99
- Jalapeno Cream CheeseDouble-whipped cream cheese with spicy jalapenos (it is actually spicy). Priced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers.$9.49
- Jalapeño Garlic Cream CheesePriced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers.$9.49
- Vegan Scallion Cream Cheese$9.49/half pound. Perfect for vegans and the lactose challenged among us.$10.99
- Vegan Cream Cheese$8.99/half pound. Perfect for vegans and the lactose challenged among us.$10.49
- Bacon Cheddar Cream CheeseHalf pound Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers.$10.99
- Olive Cream CheeseHalf pound Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers.$8.99
Salads
- Smoked Whitefish Salad$18.48/half pound. Our smoked whitefish salad is made with wild-caught whitefish from the great lakes. This is not a mayonnaise salad with some fish byproduct. This is a premium whitefish salad dressed with a little mayonnaise. It tastes like smoke and cold-water fresh fish.$19.98
- Baked Salmon Salad$18.48/half pound. Made from our rich kippered salmon, this spread is great on a bagel, bialy, or rye bread!$19.98
- Seriously Great Tuna Salad$11.99/half pound. We're not kidding. It really is seriously great!$13.49
- Chicken Salad (CONTAINS TREE NUTS)$10.99/half pound. We gently poach chickens from our friends at Los Paisanos Butcher Shop. We then break apart the pieces, and toss them with pecans, grapes, and celery. It's just a great chicken salad.$12.49
- Chopped Liver$8.99/half pound. We sauté chicken livers with onions, then hand-chop them into a chopped liver that walks the line between smooth and chunky. Duck fat, cognac, and hard-cooked eggs round out our chopped liver. It's got that rich unctuousness that makes it an irresistible classic.$10.49
- Egg Salad with Cornichons$7.49/half pound. Egg salad can be divisive. You either love it or hate it. We love it. And if you're in that camp, then you'll LOVE ours. It's got little slices of cornichons in it!$8.99
- Homemade Macaroni Salad$4.49/half pound. Macaroni salad is part of the holy trinity of delicatessen salads. In fact, it is the only acceptable form of pasta salad. We make ours with a homemade dressing that has a nice little zing to it!$5.99
- Homemade Potato Salad$4.49/half pound. I've never met a potato that I didn't like, and potato salad can really never be bad. Well, maybe it can.... But, ours is outstanding!$5.99
- Homemade Coleslaw$4.49/half pound. Nothing is worse than sad, flavorless coleslaw. Ok, yes, of course, war, famine, illness, they're all worse... But, you get what I'm sayin'. Our coleslaw though is AWESOME!$5.99
- Full Sour Pickles- 1 Qt1 Qt Size. Priced by the half pound.$9.50
Chips & Salty Things
- Cape Cod Mequite BBQ 1.37oz$1.99
- Cape Cod Original Sea Salt 1.5oz$1.99
- Cape Cod Sea Salt 5oz$6.99
- Cape Cod Salt and Vinegar 5oz$6.99
- Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs$4.99
- Pirates Booty Aged White Cedar 5oz$6.99
- Pirates Booty Aged White Cheddar 1oz$1.99
- Snack Factory Pretzel Crisps Everything Deli Style$7.00
- Macys Cheddar & Scallion Cheese Sticks$7.99
Deli Meats & Cold Cuts
- Schaller & Weber Roast TurkeySchaller & Weber makes some of the best cold cuts around, and their roast turkey fits that description. It's super juicy and flavourful!$10.49
- Homemade Roast Beef$16.99/half pound. We brine Dellapietra's rounds for 3 days before dusting them with lots of black pepper and slowly roasting them to a beautiful, rosy, pink medium-rare. We slice it thinly to order.$18.49
- Classic Delicatessen Corned Beef$16.99/half pound. Our briskets are corned with a special blend of spices. A bit leaner than pastrami, the flavor is clean with that nostalgic, jewish deli somethin' somethin'!$18.49
- BolognaForest pork store bologna is mild and silky. Priced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers$8.49
- Cooked HamForest pork store cooked ham has a clean ham flavor. Priced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers$8.49
- Braunschweiger Sliced LiverwurstForest pork store braunschweiger liverwurst is tender and sliceable. It is a personal favorite of ours. Great on rye with deli mustard and red onions. Priced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers$8.49
- Cervelatwurst Beef SalamiCervelatwurst salami is semi-dry and made with beef. Killer with butter on rye. Priced by the half pound. Want More? Add more quantities using modifiers.$8.99
- 1/4 lb Pre-Packaged, Sliced Smoked SalmonType of salmon might differ than photo depending on availability.$15.49
- Vodka Dill Smoked Salmon 4oz$15.49
- Pastrami Smoked Salmon 4oz$15.49
Knishes
- Fried Square KnishThis is a classic - a Coney Island-style, fried square potato knish.$5.49
- Baked Potato KnishThis is the standard, old-school, potato-filled knish.$5.99
- Baked Kasha KnishThese old-school knishes are filled with potato and nutty kasha (buckwheat).$5.99
- Baked Broccoli KnishThese old school knishes are filled with potato and broccoli.$5.99
Cold Beverages
- 16 Oz. Cold Brew Iced CoffeeWe cold-brew ashlawn farm’s nicaragua dark roast.$5.50
- Canned Soda$1.50
- Dr. Browns Soda Cans$3.50
- Poland Spring Water$3.00
- Martinelli's Apple Juice$4.00
- Abita root beer$4.75
- Cheerwine$5.00
- 16oz. Bottle Snapple All Natural Tea$3.50
- Yoohoo$3.50
- Blenheim Ginger Ale$6.96
- Blenheim “Hot” Ginger Ale$7.96
- Rose Hill Farms Sparkling CiderDine-in only$7.99
- Fentimans Rose Lemonade$5.99
- Sprecher Cream Soda$5.49
Hot Beverages
- Drip CoffeeAshlawn farm deterra villa borghese coffe. Rich and bold.$4.00
- Hot Box of Ashlawn Farm CoffeeThis awesome coffee comes hot in a box and serves 12. It includes cups, lids, sleeves, stirrers, milk, half and half, sugar, and sweetener$37.00
- Thé du Hammam (Vert Green tea)Green tea with notes of rose, orange blossom, berries and Turkish dates$3.00
- Rooibos Du Hammam (Smoked Red Tea)Caffeine free the rich flavor of rooibos is reminiscent of Virginia tobacco with gentle notes of rose, orange blossom and Turkish dates$3.00
- Grand Jasmin Chun Feng (Vert green tea)Incredibly subtle and without a hint of bitterness, green tea flavored with fresh jasmine flowers$3.00
- Verbena Orange Mint teaA nourishing herbal tea with verbena leaves, orange peel and mint leaves.$3.00
- Blue of London (Earl Grey)Black tea from Yunnan, paired with a fresh, delicate bergamot in a remarkably refined and perfectly balanced blend.$3.00
Snacks & Sweet Things
- Joyva Marble Halvah Bar$6.39
- Joyva Vanilla Halvah Bar$6.39
- Tates Bakeshop Chocolate Chip Cookies$6.99
- Ritter Sport Alpine Milk Chocolate Bar$5.75
- St. Michel Galettes$7.99
- Jules Destrooper Butter Waffles$7.99
- Joray CherryFruit Roll$1.99
- Joray Strawberry Fruit Roll$1.99
- Joyva Chocolate Covered Jell Rings$1.50
- St. Michel Mini Madeleines$9.99
- Joyva Sesame Crunch$12.99
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the Everything Bagel · about $10 a person
What to order
from the menuEverything Bagel
Our plain bagels coated with our own homemade everything topping.
Bagels, Bialys & Breads$1.99
Shelsky's Roast Turkey Sandwich
Our homemade, thinly-sliced roasted turkey, cole slaw, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on your choice of bread.
Shelsky's Lunch Sandwiches Our Way$20.99
Roast Beef Lunch Sandwich
Homemade roast beef on your choice of bread with your choice of toppings.
Lunch Sandwiches Your Way$11.99
Mixed Baker's Dozen
Choice of any mixture of bagels and or bialys. If you would like multiples of a certain flavor and or combination, please indicate the quantity of each in the special instructions.
Bagels, Bialys & Breads$25
Lard Bread
Mazzola bakery lard bread, a hero loaf with salami, cheese and lots of black pepper a carroll gardens italian classic.
Bagels, Bialys & Breads$9
Lox Cream Cheese
$11.49/half pound. We source our cream cheese from Rockland County, NY. It's rich, velvety, and tangy. Ground Nova is whipped into our cream cheese to make this appetizing shop and bagel store classic. As for me? I LOVE it on a poppy seed bagel. But that's me. You do you.
Cream Cheeses$12.99
Bagels — food to try
2 on this menuEverything bagel✓ On the menu · $1.99
Boiled then baked, with a chewy crust — the test of a real bagel.
Lox and cream cheese✓ On the menu · $9.49
Cured salmon, capers, red onion. The classic order.
Here it's “Bagel with Lox Cream Cheese”.
453 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY, 11215-3926
HoursAll hours ▾Hide ▴
- Monday
- 7am–1:40pm
- Tuesday
- 7am–1:40pm
- Wednesday
- 7am–1:40pm
- Thursday
- 7am–1:40pm
- Friday
- 7am–1:40pm
- Saturday
- 8am–1:40pm
- Sunday
- 8am–1:40pm
Hours from the restaurant's website — call ahead on holidays.
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedL&B Spumoni Gardens
Italian
4.6★ (11,500+)·$$

Muse Thai
Thai
4.7★ (1,500+)·1.4 mi

Black Forest Brooklyn
German
4.2★ (1,000+)·1.4 mi

Cent'Anni
Italian
4.3★ (1,000+)·1.7 mi

Werkstatt
Austrian
4.6★ (900+)·2.0 mi

Captain Dan's Good Time Tavern
American
4.4★ (800+)·2.4 mi

Tava Turkish and Mediterranean
Turkish
4.6★ (600+)·0.4 mi

Kulushkat Gourmet Falafel Corp
Brooklyn
4.0★ (500+)·1.1 mi

Brooklyn Habit
Cafe
4.4★ (500+)·0.7 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →