
Sugarberry Bakery Cafe
Bakery · Rockville Centre
By phone
orders & questions
Menu
from the website · Sep 2, 2026Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Hot Coffee & Drinks
- Drip CoffeeThe classic, morning afternoon or night get our delicious home brewed coffee.
- Cafe Au LaitThe French seem to know a thing or two about coffee. This is how they start their day!

- EspressoSingle or Double! Nitrous for your veins regardless.
- LattePlain, or flavored. Latte's are a fan favorite
- Caramel Macchiato2.0oz of greek espresso with foam and delicious caramel drizzle.

- Red EyeFresh-brewed coffee with an added espresso shot for an extra kick.
- CappuccinoClassic espresso topped with steamed milk and light foam.
- Flat WhiteSmooth espresso finished with silky steamed milk and minimal foam.
- NescafeTraditional Greek-style instant coffee, simple and familiar.

- AmericanoEspresso diluted with hot water for a clean, bold cup.

- Herbal TeaHarney & Sons tea options: - Chamomile - Green - Peppermint - Earl Grey - English Breakfast - Paris - Darjeeling
- ChaiSpiced black tea brewed with warming aromatics.
- Chai LatteSpiced chai blended with steamed milk for a creamy finish.

- Hot ChocolateRich, comforting hot chocolate made with steamed milk.

- Signature Berry Hot ChocolateOur house hot chocolate with a subtle berry twist.

- Decaf OptionsAll the flavor of our Drip and Espresso based drinks without the caffeine.
Iced Coffee & Cold Beverages
- Iced AmericanoChilled espresso poured over ice for a bold, refreshing finish.

- Iced CoffeeFresh-brewed coffee served cold over ice.

- Cold BrewSlow-steeped coffee with a smooth, low-acid profile.

- Freddo CappuccinoA classic Greek/Italian hybrid favorite with whipped espresso and cold milk foam.

- Nitro Cold BrewCreamy, nitrogen-infused cold brew with a naturally smooth texture.

- Iced LatteEspresso and cold milk poured over ice.

- Iced Red EyeFor the weary and tired, iced coffee boosted with an added espresso shot.

- Iced MochaccinoEspresso, chocolate, and milk served chilled over ice.

- Greek Style FrappeTraditional Greek iced coffee, frothy and refreshing, with flavor options available.

- Frappe FloatGreek-style frappe topped with gelato for a sweet, creamy finish

- AffogatoClassic espresso poured over gelato.

- Iced Chai LatteSpiced chai blended with cold milk over ice.
- Iced Raspberry TeaLight and refreshing iced tea with natural raspberry flavor.
- Iced Passion Fruit TeaBright and tropical passion fruit iced tea.
House-Made Milkshakes
- Chocolate ShakeRich chocolate gelato blended smooth and creamy.
- Vanilla ShakeClassic vanilla gelato shaken thick and cold.
- Strawberry Dream ShakeStrawberry gelato blended with berry cookie dough.
- Nutella MilkshakeCreamy gelato blended with Nutella.
- Caramel Sea Salt ShakeCaramel gelato blended smooth with a hint of sea salt.
- Espresso ShakeGelato blended with fresh espresso for a bold, creamy shake.
- Pistachio ShakeClassic pistachio gelato blended rich and nutty.
- Mint Chocolate Chip ShakeMint gelato with chocolate chips blended cool and refreshing.
- Cinnamon Toast ShakeCinnamon gelato with warm cereal-inspired flavor, blended thick.
- Rainbow Cookie ShakeGelato blended with classic Italian rainbow cookie flavor.
- Cannoli Cream ShakeGelato blended with classic Italian rainbow cookie flavor.
- Raspberry Sorbet ShakeTart raspberry sorbet blended into a refreshing shake.
- Mango Sorbet ShakeSmooth mango sorbet with bright tropical flavor.
Pastries (Available All Day)
- CroissantsButtery, flaky croissants baked fresh daily.
- Cheese DanishFlaky pastry filled with sweet cream cheese.
- Apple TurnoverGolden pastry filled with warm spiced apples.
- Linzer TartsClassic shortbread cookies layered with fruit preserves.
- Oatmeal Rasin CookieSoft oatmeal cookie with plump raisins and warm spice.
- Red Velvet CookieSoft red velvet cookie with rich cocoa flavor.
- Triple Chocolate CookieChocolate cookie packed with three kinds of chocolate.
- Macadamia CookieTree nutsButtery cookie loaded with white chocolate and macadamia nuts.
- M&M CookieSoft baked cookie filled with colorful chocolate candies.
- Rainbow CookiesTraditional Italian almond cake layered with jam and chocolate.
- MacaronsDelicate French almond cookies with assorted seasonal fillings.
- Fudge BrownieRich, dense chocolate brownie with a fudgy center.
- Oreo BrownieFudgy chocolate brownie swirled with Oreo pieces.
- Fudge Brownie GFGluten freeGluten-free chocolate brownie with a rich, fudgy texture.
- Gluten free EclairGluten freeClassic pastry filled with cream and topped with chocolate glaze.
- CannoliCrisp pastry shell filled with sweet ricotta cream.
- Fruit TartButtery tart shell filled with cream and topped with fresh fruit.
- Chocolate Covered StrawberriesFresh strawberries dipped in smooth chocolate.
- Gluten free Crumb CakeGluten freeMoist cake topped with a thick cinnamon crumb.
- MuffinsFresh-baked muffins in assorted daily flavors.
- Mini PastriesAssorted bite-size pastries perfect for sharing.
- BiscottiTraditional twice-baked almond or raisin cookies.
Greek Treats
- BaklavaTree nutsCrisp layers of phyllo, chopped nuts, and syrup, rich without being overwhelming.
- GalactobourekoCreamy custard baked in phyllo and finished with syrup for a smooth and balanced bite.
- Ekmek KataifiSyrup-soaked shredded phyllo topped with custard and cream, rich and indulgent from start to finish.
- KataifiTree nutsCrispy shredded phyllo wrapped around nuts and soaked in syrup for a perfectly textured classic.
- KaridopitaTree nutsMoist walnut cake lightly spiced and soaked in syrup, simple and satisfying.
- PortokalopitaOrange-forward phyllo cake with bright citrus flavor and a soft, syrupy finish.
- Kourabiedes CookieButtery almond shortbread dusted in powdered sugar that melts as you eat it.
- Melomakarona CookiesMelomakarona Cookies – Spiced honey-soaked cookies finished with walnuts, classic and comforting.
- Koulourakia CookieLight, slightly sweet butter cookies baked until golden and crisp.
- KokSmall, syrup-soaked pastry puffs filled with rich vanilla pastry cream and covered in a shiny chocolate glaze.
- FanouropitaVeganGreek vegan spice cake made in honor of Saint Fanourios, the patron saint of lost things!
Cakes (single-slice / cake descriptions)
- Vegan CakeIt doesn't have to be your birthday to grab a slice of our delicious cake.
- Birthday CakeBirthdays are a time for fun colors and delicious flavors the whole family will enjoy!
- Black and White CakeCan't decide between Vanilla or Chocolate. The black and white cake combines both amazing flavors so you don't have to.
- Carrot CakeA decadent moist, spiced cake using grated carrots packed with warm spices. Famously topped with a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting.
- Cannoli CakeCannoli cream on cake is marrying two delectable partners for one great experience!
- Chocolate Mouse CakeDecadent high quality chocolate is used for our classic house made chocolate cake.
- Napoleon CakeAlso called the mille fleur. European dessert made of numerous thin, flaky puff pastry layers and a rich, smooth pastry cream filling
- Oreo CakeOne of the best cookies, in one of the best cakes, sounds like a combo made in heaven!
- Red Velvet CakeRich, spongey, tangy the red velvet cake is one to try.
- Sugarbbery CakeSoft vanilla cake layered with fresh berries and lightly sweetened cream.
- Strawberry ShortcakeA magnificent combination of fluffy cake, strawberries and cream
- TiramisuA classic Italian dessert made of coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with a rich mascarpone cheese based cream, then topped with a dusting of cocoa powder. Contains Alchohol
- Truffa CakeA cake with mixed fresh cream, vanilla, and chocolate, then coated the ganache with melted dark chocolate and rolled it in cocoa powder!
- Strawberry Tres LechesAn incredibly moist, rich, and tender cake, consisting of a light, airy sponge cake soaked in a sweet mixture of three different types of milk.
- Lemon CoconutLight lemon cake layered with coconut and lightly sweetened cream.
- CheesecakeA certified New York classic.
- New York CheesecakeThe certified classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about!
- Sugar Free CheesecakeThe certified Sugar Free classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about!
- Carmel CheesecakeGooey caramel on great cheesecake is a match made in heaven!
- Baklava CheesecakeAdding Baklava to anything is great, especially cheesecake!
- Chocolate CheesecakeRich chocolate in our house made rich creamy cheesecake.
- Oreo CheesecakeOne of the worlds best cookies crumbled into the NY Bakery Cafe's signature cheesecake.
- Red Velvet CheesecakeDark and rich red velvet layered with New York style cheesecake.
- Strawberry CheesecakeStrawberry filling on top of our world famous cheesecake.
- Berry CheesecakeTasty, Sweet and Fruity goodness all on our awesome cheesecake!
- Crème Brule CheesecakeThe golden combo, delectable rich caramelized sugar on our famous cheesecake.
Cupcakes & Cake Pops
- Vanilla CupcakeClassic vanilla cupcake finished with sprinkles and vanilla frosting.
- Chocolate Fudge CupcakeRich chocolate cupcake with deep fudge flavor and smooth frosting.
- Red Velvet CupcakeBite-size red velvet cake dipped and finished on a stick.
- Oreo CupcakeChocolate cupcake topped with cookies-and-cream frosting and Oreo pieces.
- Elmo CupcakeVanilla cupcake topped with bright frosting.
- Strawberry Milkshake CupcakeVanilla cupcake topped with strawberry milkshake-style frosting.
- Cookie Monster CupcakeChocolate chip cupcake topped with cookies-and-cream frosting.
- Churro CupcakeCinnamon-spiced cupcake finished with sweet churro-style frosting.
- Carrot CupcakeMoist carrot cupcake topped with smooth cream cheese frosting.
- Rainbow CupcakeColorful vanilla cake topped with smooth frosting, classic and fun.
- M&M CupcakeVanilla cupcake topped with chocolate frosting and M&M candies.
- Vanilla Cake-PopClassic vanilla cake blended and dipped in chocolate.
- Chocolate Cake-PopRich chocolate cake blended and dipped in chocolate.
- Red Velvet Cake-PopRed velvet cake blended with cream cheese and dipped in chocolate.
- Oreo Cake-PopChocolate cake blended with Oreo cookie pieces and dipped in chocolate.
- Funfetti Cake-PopVanilla cake mixed with colorful sprinkles and dipped in chocolate.
Hot Items
- BougastaTraditional Greek pastry filled with warm custard and layered in crisp phyllo.
- CroissantsButtery, flaky croissants baked fresh daily.
- Spinach / Spanakopita (Pie Slice)Spinach, herbs, and cheese wrapped in crisp phyllo for a balanced, savory bite.
- Cheese/ Tiropita (Pie Slice)Flaky phyllo filled with a rich, savory cheese blend, baked until golden.
- PuddingThe two P's! Bread Pudding A creamy, subtly sweet, and comforting, desert like a mellow, thick porridge made from rice and cream. Contains Alchohol
- Creme BruleGluten freeRich custard with a tasty glass like sugar topping. One of the best deserts out there! Gluten free
- FlanGluten freeA sweet custard desert with a layer of delicious caramel on top. Gluten free
- Pie by the Slice - Pecan PieA beloved Southern holiday staple featuring crunchy pecans in a gooey, custard-like filling.
- Pie by the Slice - Apple PieNothing's as American as Apple Pie, at least the saying goes. Our apple pie is also Homemade!
Gelato
- Pistachio GelatoRich pistachio gelato with a smooth, nutty flavor.
- Mint Chip GelatoCool mint gelato with chocolate chip pieces.
- Stracciatella GelatoClassic vanilla gelato with thin ribbons of chocolate.
- Rainbow Cookie GelatoGelato inspired by classic Italian rainbow cookies.
- Cannoli Cream GelatoSweet ricotta-style gelato with cannoli cream flavor.
- Caramel Sea Salt GelatoCreamy caramel gelato finished with a touch of sea salt.
- Vanilla GelatoSmooth, classic vanilla gelato.
- Chocolate GelatoRich and creamy chocolate gelato.
- Cinnamon GelatoWarm cinnamon-spiced gelato with a smooth finish.
- Nutella GelatoChocolate-hazelnut gelato blended rich and creamy.
- Strawberry Cookie Dough GelatoStrawberry gelato swirled with cookie dough pieces.
- Strawberry Banana GelatoSmooth strawberry gelato blended with ripe banana flavor.
- Raspberry SorbetBright, tart raspberry sorbet with a refreshing finish. Dairy free

- Passion Fruit SorbetTropical passion fruit sorbet, light and vibrant. Dairy free
- Lemon SorbetFresh lemon sorbet with a crisp citrus bite. Dairy free

- Mango SorbetSweet, tropical mango sorbet blended smooth. Dairy free
Whole Pies & Cakes (Whole)
- Whole Apple PieNothing's as American as Apple Pie, at least the saying goes. Our apple pie is also Homemade!$22.00
- Whole Pecan PieA beloved Southern holiday staple featuring crunchy pecans in a gooey, custard-like filling.$23.00
- Whole Raspberry Apricot PieButtery pie filled with sweet raspberries and apricots.$23.00
- Whole Coconut Custard PieAn old-fashioned dessert featuring a rich, creamy filling loaded with sweetened shredded coconut.$23.00
- Whole Blueberry PieGooey sweet blueberry pie filling is always delectable inside our homemade pic crust.$22.00
- Whole Cherry PieHomemade flaky, buttery pastry crust filled with a sweet-tart cherry filling.$22.00
- Whole Apple Crumb PieSometimes known as a Dutch apple pie, it has all the goodness of a classic apple pie with a delicious crumbly streusel topping$23.00
- Whole New York CheesecakeThe certified classic. Creamy and delectable our house made cheesecake is something to write home about! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Strawberry CheesecakeStrawberry filling on top of our famous cheesecake. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Berry CheesecakeThe Sugarberry Special! Tasty, Sweet and Fruity goodness all on our awesome cheesecake! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Caramel CheesecakeGooey caramel on great cheesecake is a match made in heaven! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Oreo CheesecakeOne of the worlds best cookies crumbled into Sugarberry Cafe's signature cheesecake. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Tiramisu CakeA classic Italian dessert "Cake-fied" made of coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with a rich mascarpone cheese based cream, then topped with a dusting of cocoa powder. Small Serves: 6–8 people$35.00
- Whole Red Velvet CakeRich, spongey, tangy the red velvet cake is one to try. Small Serves: 6–8 people$35.00
- Whole Birthday CakeBirthdays are a time for fun colors and delicious flavors the whole family will enjoy! Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Chocolate CakeMoist chocolate cake, a light and airy chocolate mousse filling, Topped with a rich chocolate ganache. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Black & White CakeCan't decide between Vanilla or Chocolate. The black and white cake combines both amazing flavors so you don't have to. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Strawberry Tres Leches CakeAn incredibly moist, rich, and tender cake, consisting of a light, airy sponge cake soaked in a sweet mixture of three different types of milk. Small Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people
- Whole Carrot CakeA decadent moist, spiced cake using grated carrots packed with warm spices. Famously topped with a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting. Small Serves: 6–8 people$35.00
- Whole Sugarberry CakeSoft vanilla cake layered with fresh berries and lightly sweetened cream. Medium Serves: 10–14 people$47.00
- Whole Strawberry Tres LechesSmall Serves: 6–8 people Medium Serves: 10–14 people Small $35 Medium $45
Platters & Special Orders
- Small Cookie Platter (1.5lbs)Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are always a hit.$29.95
- Large Cookie Platter (2.5lbs)Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are easy to share and always a hit.$39.95
- Gluten Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)Gluten freePerfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are always a hit.$18.95
- Gluten free Sugar Free Cookie Platter (1.0lbs)Gluten free · Sugar freeSame great cookies, no added sugar.$18.95
- Large Fruit TartA beautiful dessert with a crisp, buttery pastry crust, Creamy filling and beautifully arranged fruits.$35.00
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the Rainbow Cookie Shake · about $23 a person
What to order
from the menuRainbow Cookie Shake
Gelato blended with classic Italian rainbow cookie flavor.
House-Made Milkshakes
Small Cookie Platter (1.5lbs)
Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are always a hit.
Platters & Special Orders$29.95
Large Cookie Platter (2.5lbs)
Perfect for parties, these trays of house-made cookies are easy to share and always a hit.
Platters & Special Orders$39.95
Whole Apple Crumb Pie
Sometimes known as a Dutch apple pie, it has all the goodness of a classic apple pie with a delicious crumbly streusel topping
Whole Pies & Cakes (Whole)$23
Whole Tiramisu Cake
A classic Italian dessert "Cake-fied" made of coffee-soaked ladyfingers layered with a rich mascarpone cheese based cream, then topped with a dusting of cocoa powder. Small Serves: 6–8 people
Whole Pies & Cakes (Whole)$35
Linzer Tarts
Classic shortbread cookies layered with fruit preserves.
Pastries (Available All Day)
Bakery — food to try
1 on this menuCookie✓ On the menu
The chocolate chip cookie tells you if they respect butter.
Here it's “Rainbow Cookie Shake”.
312 Sunrise Hwy, Rockville Centre, NY, 11570
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedL&B Spumoni Gardens
Italian
4.6★ (11,500+)·$$

Island Buffet Hibachi Grill
Buffet
4.2★ (1,500+)·1.9 mi

Organic Krush Kitchen & Eatery
Health food
4.2★ (100+)·0.1 mi

Chill Soft Serve
Dessert
4.7★ (100+)·1.5 mi

Moe's Southwest Grill
Texmex
3.9★ (600+)·1.2 mi

batch
Bakery
0.2 mi

Viaggio Italian Chop House
Italian
0.1 mi

Red Crab Juicy Seafood
Seafood
0.1 mi

American Burgers
Burger
0.1 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →



.jpg)