Butler's Flat
Seafood · Port Washington
By phone
orders & questions
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the Lobster Roll · about $13 a person
What to order
from the menuLobster Roll
1/4 pound of Maine lobster, mayo, celery on a griddled New England roll served with french fries
Sandwiches$30
Crispy Shrimp Roll
fried rock shrimp, sriracha mayo and scallions on a griddled New England roll served with french fries
Sandwiches$18
Fried Flounder Sandwich
fried Montauk flounder, lettuce, tomato, tartare sauce and lemon on a hero served with french fries
Sandwiches$23
Whole Belly Clams
fried whole belly clams, tartar sauce, lemon, French fries & slaw
Seafood Platters$29
Sea Scallops
baked sea scallops with farro salad and roasted seasonal vegetables OR fried scallops with tartare sauce, lemon, French fries & slaw
Seafood Platters$27
Gulf Shrimp
baked Gulf shrimp with farro salad and roasted seasonal vegetables OR fried shrimp with cocktail sauce, lemon, French fries & slaw
Seafood Platters$25
Seafood — food to try
1 on this menuLobster roll✓ On the menu · $30
Cold with mayo or warm with butter; both camps are right.
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-01Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Appetizers
Sandwiches
Salads
Seafood Platters
Sides
Ice Cream
BeerDine-in only
Cider & Hard TeaDine-in only
WineDine-in only
Soft Drinks
86 Orchard Beach Blvd, Port Washington, NY, 11050
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedMango Mango Dessert - Huntington
Dessert
4.8★ (200+)
Nino’s Beach
Mediterranean
4.2★ (600+)·0.1 mi
Louie's Prime Steak & Seafood
Seafood
1.1 mi
The One Bakery
Bakery
0.4 mi
Fly Chick to the Moon
Korean
0.5 mi
Margaritas Cafe
Mexican
0.5 mi
Paradice
Dessert
0.6 mi
Pepe Rosso 24
Italian
0.7 mi
Tutto Burger
Burger
0.7 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →