Make My Cake
Bakery · New York
Closed
opens 11am today
By phone
orders & questions
What to order
from the menuCookie & Cream Cake
Each
Cake Slices$8.75
Specialty Cupcakes
Cupcakes$30
6' Sweet Potato Pie
6' serves 5. 8' serves 10. 10' serves 16
Signature Pies$15
Vanilla Buttercream (Butter Cake)
Classic & Signature Cakes$75
Chocolate Frosted (Butter Cake)
Classic & Signature Cakes$75
Strawberry Frosted (Butter Cake)
Classic & Signature Cakes$75
Bakery — food to try
1 on this menuCookie✓ On the menu · $8.75
The chocolate chip cookie tells you if they respect butter.
Here it's “Cookie & Cream Cake”.
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-02Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Cupcakes
- Vegan Cupcakes$25.50
- Regular Cupcake$25.50
- Specialty Cupcakes$30.00
Classic & Signature Cakes
- Vanilla Buttercream (Butter Cake)$75.00
- Chocolate Frosted (Butter Cake)$75.00
- Strawberry Frosted (Butter Cake)$75.00
- Lemon Frosted (Butter Cake)$75.00
- Coconut Pineapple (Butter Cake)$75.00
- Red & White Cake$75.00
- Black & White Cake$100.00
- Carrot Cake$85.00
- Red Velvet Cake$85.00
- Double Chocolate Cake$85.00
- German Chocolate Cake$525.00
Mini Cheesecakes
- NY Style Cheesecake$8.50
- Red Velvet Cheesecake$8.50
- Sweet Potato Cheesecake$8.50
- Strawberry Cheesecake$8.50
- Cherry Cheesecake$8.50
- Pineapple Cheesecake$8.50
- Lemon Cheesecake$8.50
Cake Slices
- Buttercream CakeEach$8.75
- Caramel Frosted CakeEach$8.75
- Chocolate Layer CakeEach$8.75
- Coconut Pineapple CakeEach$8.75
- Coconut Cream CakeEach$8.75
- Lemon Frosted CakeEach$8.75
- Double Chocolate CakeEach$8.75
- Chocolate Cream CakeEach$8.75
- German Chocolate CakeEach$8.75
- Carrot CakeEach$8.75
- Cookie & Cream CakeEach$8.75
- Black N White CakeEach$8.75
- Red & White CakeEach$8.75
- Red Velvet CakeEach$8.75
- Strawberry Frosted CakeEach$8.75
- Black & Red CakeEach$8.75
- Tres Leches CakeEach$8.75
Pies and Cobblers
- SmallServes 1-3 people$16.50
- Cobbler1/2 pan$85.00
Signature Pies
- 6' Sweet Potato Pie6' serves 5. 8' serves 10. 10' serves 16$15.00
775 Columbus Ave, New York, NY, 10025
Closed· opens 11am todayAll hours ▾Hide ▴
- Sunday (today)
- 11am–6pm
- Monday
- 11am–7:30pm
- Tuesday
- 11am–7:30pm
- Wednesday
- 11am–7:30pm
- Thursday
- 11am–7:30pm
- Friday
- 11am–7:30pm
- Saturday
- 11am–7:30pm
Hours from the restaurant's website — call ahead on holidays.
