
Old John's Diner
American · New York
By phone
orders & questions
Menu
from the website · Sep 1, 2026Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Breakfast Sandwiches
- LOXScramble eggs, gravlax, cream cheese, red onion, tomato on brioche roll$14.00
- CHEF RAUL’S FAVScrambled eggs, chorizo, mozzarella, avocado, refried beans, on a Portuguese roll with pickled jalapeños on the side$14.00
- WEST SIDEScrambled eggs, Mozzarella, avocado, sausage, on a brioche roll$12.00
- THE KATHYScrambled eggs, bacon, cheese, on a homemade biscuit$14.00
- Bacon, Eggs and CheeseON A BRIOCHE ROLL$12.00
Healthy Start
Coffee
Waffles, Pancakes & More
- BUTTERMILK PANCAKESSERVED WITH MAPLE SYRUP AND BUTTER$15.00
- CHALLAH FRENCH TOASTSERVED WITH MAPLE SYRUP AND BUTTER$15.00
- CINNAMON APPLE PANCAKESSERVED WITH MAPLE SYRUP AND BUTTER$18.00
- STUFFED FRENCH TOASTChallah bread stuffed with mascarpone cheese, cream cheese, strawberries, and served with strawberry compote, fresh blueberries and caramel sauce$20.00
- CLASSIC WAFFLESERVED WITH MAPLE SYRUP AND BUTTER$15.00
- FRITATA HAMPotatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast$17.00
- FRITATA SPINACH-FETAPotatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast$18.00
Eggs Your Way
- POTATO LATKESWith gravlax, two fried eggs, arugula, lemon vinaigrette$18.00
- AVOCADO TOASTTwo poached eggs, paprika and red pepper flakes on sourdough toast, guacamole, watermelon radish, tomato, arugula, lemon vinaigrette, home fries$17.00
- TWO EGGS ANY STYLEWith home fries and toast$14.00
- SHAKSHUKATwo eggs baked in tomato sauce, toast on the side$19.00
- CORNED BEEF HASH AND EGGSBell peppers, onions, two poached eggs, bernaise tarragon sauce, toast on the side$20.00
- BURRITOScrambled eggs, Mexican chorizo, black beans, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro and onion wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with pico de gallo$15.00
- CHILAQUILESCrispy corn tortillas in choice of green tomatillo or guajillo-tomato salsa, two sunny-side up eggs, avocado, queso fresco, crema$16.00
- HUEVOS RANCHEROSTwo sunny side up eggs, salsa verde, black beans, crema, pickled onions, queso fresco, on crispy corn tortillas$17.00
- STEAK & EGGSSirloin steak, two eggs any style, home fries$26.00
- EGGS BENEDICTTwo poached eggs, Canadian bacon, English muffin, hollandaise sauce, served with home fries$18.00
- SPINACH SALMON BENEDICTTwo poached eggs, gravlax, sautéed spinach, English muffin, hollandaise sauce, served with home fries$19.00
- HASH & EGGSBeef short ribs, potatoes, scallions, chile de arbol, roasted peppers, two sunny side up eggs$20.00
- LORRAINESoft scrambled, onions, served with a side of white fish salad, onions, tomatoes, sliced cucumbers, and a Bagel$20.00
Omelette
Breakfast Specials
- 2 EGGS ANY STYLEWith home fries and toast Coffee or tea + Fresh Squeezed orange juice$16.00
- FRENCH TOAST OR PANCAKESCHOICE OF COFFEE, OR TEA + FRESH SQUEEZED ORANGE JUICE$17.00
- OMELETTE WESTERN OR HAM & CHEESEWith home fries and toast Coffee or tea + Fresh Squeezed orange juice$18.00
- 2 SOFT BOILED EGGS WITH SOLDIERSCoffee or tea + Fresh Squeezed orange juice$16.00
Brunch Omelettes
Entrees (Brunch/Lunch)
Sandwiches (Brunch)
- OLD JOHNS BURGER8oz. Angus steak, white cheddar, onion, lettuce, tomato, sesame bun$16.00
- WARM CHICKEN CLUBGrilled chicken, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato aioli, bacon, avocado, grilled red onion, tomato, romaine, on wheat toast$17.00
- CLASSIC BLTBacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, on grilled challah bread$15.00
- TURKEY CLUB TRIPLE DECKERRoasted turkey, BLT, mayo, on white toast$18.00
- GRILLED CHEESENYS cheddar, fontina fontal, smoked gouda, on grilled challah bread$15.00
- TUNA MELTTuna salad, NYS cheddar, fontina fontal, on grilled challah bread$18.00
Salads
Sweet Start
Brunch Specialties
- THE LEOOpen faced omelette, with house salmon, carmelized onions, crème fraiche, dill, served with a latke and toast$24.00
- HUEVOS RANCHEROSTwo sunny side up eggs, salsa verde, black beans, crema, pickled onions, and queso fresco, on crispy corn tortillas$18.00
- AVOCADO TOASTTwo poached eggs, paprika and red pepper flakes on sourdough toast, guacamole, watermelon radish, tomato, arugula, lemon vinaigrette, home fries$17.00
- EGGS BENEDICTTwo poached eggs, Canadian bacon, English muffin, hollandaise sauce, served with home fries$18.00
- SPINACH SALMON BENEDICTTwo poached eggs, gravlax, sautéed spinach, English muffin, hollandaise sauce, served with home fries$19.00
- TWO EGGS ANY STYLEWith home fries and toast$14.00
- STEAK & EGGSSirloin steak, two eggs any style, home fries$27.00
- POTATO LATKESWith gravlax, two fried eggs, arugula, lemon vinaigrette$20.00
- SHAKSHUKATwo eggs baked in tomato sauce, salsa verde, toast on the side$21.00
- HASH AND EGGSBeef short ribs, potatoes, scallions, chile de arbol, roasted peppers, two sunny side up eggs$20.00
- FRITATAHAM 18 | SPINACH-FETA 19 Potatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast
- CORNED BEEF HASH AND EGGSCorned Beef, potatoes, bell peppers, onions, two poached eggs, bernaise tarragon sauce, toast on the side$23.00
- CHILAQUILESCrispy corn tortillas in choice of green tomatillo or guajillo-tomato salsa, two sunny-side up eggs, avocado, queso fresco, crema$17.00
- BURRITOScrambled eggs, Mexican chorizo, black beans, home fries, chihuahua cheese, cilantro, and onion wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with pico de gallo and home fries$16.00
- CHICKEN & WAFFLECrispy, organic fried chicken, waffle, melted cheddar cheese, maple syrup$25.00
- STUFFED FRENCH TOASTChallah bread stuffed with mascarpone cheese, cream cheese, and served with caramel sauce, and strawberries$21.00
- BROOKLYN FRENCH TOASTFresh bananas, blueberries, and strawberries cooked in a honey glaze and served on challah twist French toast$20.00
Egg Sandwiches
- LOXScrambled eggs, gravlax, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, on a brioche roll$14.00
- BACON, EGG & CHEESEFried eggs, cheese, and bacon, on a brioche roll$12.00
- THE KATHYScrambled eggs, bacon, cheese, on a homemade biscuit$14.00
- WEST SIDEScrambled eggs, Mozzarella, avocado, sausage, on a brioche roll$12.00
- CHEF RAUL’S FAVScrambled eggs, chorizo, mozzarella, avocado, refried beans, on a Portuguese roll with pickled jalapenos on the side$14.00
Cocktails
- OLD JOHN’S GIMLETDine-in onlyAbsolut Elyx, grapefruit, lemon juice, aquafaba$15.00
- UWS MANHATTANDine-in onlyMaker’s Mark, Dolin Rouge Sweet Vermouth, bitters
- BROADWAY MOJITODine-in onlyBacardí Superior, muddled lime, mint, sugar, club soda
- ESPRESSO MARTINIGrey Goose vodka, espresso, coffee liqueur blend, Demerara syrup
- HIBISCUS MARGARITADine-in onlyReposado Tequila or Mezcal, hibiscus-ginger syrup, lime,tajin-hibiscus rim
- AMSTERDAM AVE WHISKEY SOURDine-in onlyJapanese whiskey, lemon juice,sugar, aquafaba
- 1951 SAZERACDine-in onlySazerac Rye Whiskey, Absinthe, Angostura, Peychaud’s bitters
- MARGARITADine-in onlyCazadores blanco, Cointreau, lime, frozen or on the rocks
- PINK CADILLACDine-in onlyFrozen margarita, Aperol aperitivo and lime
Brunch CocktailsDine-in only
Beers
Milkshakes & Egg Creams
Soft Drinks
Lunch Appetizers
Sandwiches & Burgers (Lunch)
- OLD JOHN’S BURGER8oz Angus beef, white cheddar, onions, lettuce, tomato, on a sesame bun$16.00
- VEGGIE BURGERChickpea and quinoa patty, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, Old John’s sauce, on a sesame bun$15.00
- TURKEY BURGEROrganic ground turkey, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, on a white roll$15.00
- PATTY MELT8oz Angus beef, caramelized onions, Russian dressing, and cheddar on grilled challah bread$16.00
- FRENCH DIP SANDWICHHot roast beef, melted Swiss, and mozzarella cheese, on ciabatta, beef au jus on the side$17.00
- WARM CHICKEN CLUBGrilled chicken, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato aioli, bacon, avocado, grilled red onion, tomato, romaine, on wheat toast$17.00
- CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICHCrispy buttermilk chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles, & chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll$15.00
- TURKEY CLUB TRIPLE DECKERRoasted turkey, BLT, mayo, on white toast$17.00
- TUNA MELTTuna salad, cheddar, fontina fontal, on grilled challah bread$16.00
- BLACKENED FISH SANDWICHIcelandic cod, homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, on a brioche roll$18.00
- GRILLED CHEESECheddar, fontina fontal, smoked gouda, on grilled challah bread$14.00
- BLTBacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, on grilled challah bread$14.00
- REUBENCorned Beef, sauerkraut, Russian dressing, Swiss cheese, on rye toast$16.00
- CHICKEN SALADWalnuts, celery, apples, onion, carrots, mayo, arugula, tomato, on a brioche bun$15.00
Lunch Sides
- FRENCH FRIES$7.00
- SAUTÉED SPINACH$7.00
- MASHED POTATOES$7.00
- BROCCOLINI (Grilled or steamed)Lemon vinaigrette, panko, shallots$7.00
- GREEN BEANSWith brown butter, & almonds$7.00
- TRUFFLE FRIESParmesan, garlic aioli$10.00
- CRISPY BRUSSELS SPROUTSBraised in garlic, shallots, thyme, arugula, parmesan$11.00
- SWEET POTATO FRIES$9.00
- HOUSE SALAD$7.00
Soup & Salads
- CHICKEN SOUPHomemade chicken broth, pulled chicken, noodles, vegetables$8.00
- MATZO BALL SOUPChicken consommé, matzo meal dumplings, celery, carrots, dill$10.00
- COBB SALADRomaine, baby arugula, blue cheese, cherry tomatoes, boiled egg, bacon, grilled chicken, homemade buttermilk ranch dressing$20.00
- GREEK SALADRomaine, feta cheese, tomato, pickled red onion, cucumber, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, fried chickpeas, Greek dressing, homemade focaccia bread$16.00
- CAESAR SALADRomaine, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing$14.00
Lunch Entrees
- MY MOMMA’S MEATLOAFMashed potatoes, french beans, almonds, brown gravy$24.00
- STEAK & FRITES12 oz Prime New York Steak, sauce verte, french fries$32.00
- SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLSMarinara sauce, Parmesan, & burrata cheese, basil, homemade foccacia$24.00
- ROASTED WILD SALMONSautéed spinach, Tuscan salad, warmed quinoa with brunoise vegetables and pesto sauce$28.00
- FISH AND CHIPSTempura crispy cod, french fries, homemade tartar sauce on the side$26.00
- RIGATONI A LA VODKACreamy marinara, vodka, Parmesan, fresh basil, served with focaccia$19.00
- RIGATONI AL PESTOBroccoli pesto, mushrooms, peas, red onion, asparagus, Parmesan, ricotta, served with focaccia$22.00
- COD FISH OREGANATAOver sautéed baby carrots, string beans & snow peas with lemon butter herb sauce$25.00
All Day Breakfast
- HAM & CHEESE OMELETTECheese of your choice, potatoes, and toast$17.00
- WESTERN OMELETTEHam, pepper, onions, potatoes, and toast$17.00
- SPINACH MUSHROOM OMELETTEMelted gruyère, potatoes, and toast$17.00
- CHALLAH FRENCH TOASTMaple syrup, butter$15.00
- BUTTERMILK PANCAKESMaple syrup, butter$15.00
- STEAK AND EGGSSirloin steak, two eggs any style, home fries$26.00
- TWO EGGS ANY STYLEPotatoes and toast$14.00
Lunch Cocktails (repeated)
- OLD JOHN’S GIMLETDine-in onlyAbsolut Elyx, grapefruit, lemon juice, aquafaba$15.00
- CLASSIC OLD FASHIONEDDine-in onlyGreat Jones bourbon, sugar, Angostura bitters
- UWS MANHATTANDine-in onlyMaker’s Mark, Dolin Rouge Sweet Vermouth, bitters
- LINCOLN CENTER MARTINIDine-in onlyAbsolut Elyx Vodka, Vermouth, dirty or dry, blue chesse olives or lemon twist
- AMSTERDAM AVE WHISKEY SOURDine-in onlyJapanese whiskey, lemon juice, sugar, aquafaba
- ESPRESSO MARTINIGrey Goose vodka, espresso, coffee liqueur blend, demerara syrup
- HIBISCUS MARGARITADine-in onlyReposado Tequila or Mezcal, hibiscus-ginger syrup, lime, tajin-hibiscus rim
- BROADWAY MOJITODine-in onlyBacardí Superior, muddled lime, mint, sugar, club soda
- 1951 SAZERACDine-in onlySazerac Rye Whiskey, Absinthe, Angostura, Peychaud’s bitters
- PINK CADILLACDine-in onlyFrozen margarita, Aperol aperitivo and lime
- MARGARITADine-in onlyCazadores Blanco, Cointreau, lime, agave, frozen or on the rocks
Beers & Wines (repeated)
Sweets
- WARM BROWNIEWarm cast iron skillet baked brownie, homemade mint chocolate chip ice cream, mocha crème anglaise$12.00
- CHURRO SUNDAEVanilla ice cream, dulce de leche sauce, crispy feuilletine, vanilla whipped cream$12.00
- TRES LECHES CAKESponge cake soaked in “tres leches”, topped with fresh whipped cream and berries$10.00
Ice Cream Sodas & Milkshakes
Cakes & Pies
Ice Cream (by scoop)
- Single Scoop$5.00
- Double Scoop$8.00
- FlavorsTAHITIAN VANILLA BEAN DARK CHOCOLATE STRAWBERRY FRESH MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP ROASTED BANANA TOASTED COCONUT SOUR CHERRY (SORBET)
- ICE CREAM SUNDAETahitian vanilla bean, caramel popcorn, chocolate crumb crunch, chocolate sauce, chantilly whipped cream, Amarena cherry$12.00
- BANANA SPLITBananas, roasted banana ice cream, toasted coconut ice cream, caramel sauce, chopped roasted almonds, almond crumble$12.00
Dinner Appetizers
- ARANCINICrispy rice balls with mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, truffle essence, Parmesan, arrabiatta sauce$15.00
- MILAN’S MEATBALLSFresh tomato sauce, Parmesan, and mozzarella$14.00
- MOZZARELLA STICKSWith homemade marinara sauce$14.00
- MAC & CHEESE3 cheese Mac & Cheese, panko crumbs$14.00
- CRAB CAKEMix of crab meat and shrimp with jalapeño, cilantro, tartar sauce, watermelon radish, and upland cress$17.00
- DEVILED EGGSClassic style topped with crispy bacon (4 pieces)$8.00
Dinner Sandwiches & Burgers
- OLD JOHN’S BURGER8oz Angus beef, white cheddar, onions, lettuce, tomato, on a sesame bun$16.00
- VEGGIE BURGERChickpea and quinoa patty, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, Old John’s sauce, on a sesame bun$15.00
- TURKEY BURGEROrganic ground turkey, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, on a white roll$15.00
- PATTY MELT8oz Angus beef, caramelized onions, Russian dressing, and cheddar, on grilled challah bread$17.00
- FRENCH DIP SANDWICHHot roast beef, melted Swiss, and mozzarella cheese, on ciabatta, beef au jus on the side$18.00
- WARM CHICKEN CLUBGrilled chicken, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato aioli, bacon, avocado, grilled red onion, tomato, romaine, on wheat toast$17.00
- CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICHCrispy buttermilk chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles, & chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll$16.00
- TURKEY CLUB TRIPLE DECKERRoasted turkey, BLT, mayo, on white toast$18.00
- TUNA MELTTuna salad, cheddar, fontina fontal, on grilled challah bread$17.00
- BLACKENED FISH SANDWICHIcelandic cod, homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, on a brioche roll$18.00
- GRILLED CHEESECheddar, fontina fontal, smoked gouda, on grilled challah bread$15.00
- BLTBacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, on grilled challah bread$15.00
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH · about $17 a person
What to order
from the menuCRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH
Crispy buttermilk chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles, & chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll
Sandwiches & Burgers (Lunch)$15
BLACKENED FISH SANDWICH
Icelandic cod, homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, on a brioche roll
Sandwiches & Burgers (Lunch)$18
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS
Marinara sauce, Parmesan, & burrata cheese, basil, homemade foccacia
Lunch Entrees$24
FISH AND CHIPS
Tempura crispy cod, french fries, homemade tartar sauce on the side
Lunch Entrees$26
OLD JOHNS BURGER
8oz. Angus steak, white cheddar, onion, lettuce, tomato, sesame bun
Sandwiches (Brunch)$16
CLASSIC BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, on grilled challah bread
Sandwiches (Brunch)$15
American — food to try
3 on this menuBurger✓ On the menu · $16
The dish every American kitchen gets judged on. Ask how they cook it.
Here it's “OLD JOHNS BURGER”.
Fried chicken sandwich✓ On the menu · $15
Brined, fried, pickles — the last decade's signature sandwich.
Here it's “CRISPY CHICKEN SANDWICH”.
Mac and cheese✓ On the menu · $14
Baked with a crust or stovetop and creamy; both are right.
Here it's “MAC & CHEESE”.
148 W 67th St, New York, NY, 10023-5922
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedKatz's Deli
Sandwiches
4.5★ (55,000+)·$$

Hard Rock Cafe New York
American
4.4★ (25,000+)·1.1 mi

Koren Bbq
Korean
4.7★ (19,000+)·1.9 mi

Shake Shack
Burger
4.5★ (7,500+)·2.3 mi

TONCHIN NEW YORK
Japanese
4.6★ (4,000+)·1.7 mi

Bierhaus NYC
German
4.3★ (3,500+)·1.7 mi

Taco Bell
Taco
4.0★ (2,500+)·1.9 mi

Capizzi
Italian
4.6★ (2,000+)·1.3 mi

St. Pat's Bar and Grill
Bar and grill
4.5★ (2,000+)·1.3 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →




