Petee's Cafe
Cafe · New York
By phone
orders & questions
What to order
from the menuMaple Whipped Cream
Housemade Whipped Cream with Vermont Maple Syrup, Vanilla, and a touch of salt
Ice Cream & Slice Cream$3
Fresh Jersey Peach
Seasonal Specials$8.85
Guava Mascarpone
Seasonal Specials$8.85
Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
Ice Cream & Slice Cream$3
Hudson Valley Apple
Fresh Baked Pies$7.99
Apple Crumb*
Fresh Baked Pies$7.99
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-02Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Fresh Baked Pies
- Hudson Valley Apple$7.99
- Apple Crumb*$7.99
- NY Sour Cherry$7.99
- Cherry Crumb*$7.99
- Wild Maine Blueberry$7.99
- Blueberry Crumb*$7.99
- Salty Chocolate Chess$7.99
- Brown Butter Honey Pecan*$7.99
- Coconut Custard$7.99
Ice Box Pies
- Banana Cream$8.85
- Lavish Chocolate Cream$8.85
- Key Lime Meringue*$8.85
- Petee's Cheesecake$8.85
Seasonal Specials
- Fresh Jersey Peach$8.85
- Guava Mascarpone$8.85
Ice Cream & Slice Cream
- Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream$3.00
- Slice Cream Housemade Vanilla Bean Ice Cream churned with chunks of: Pecan Pie OR Salty Chocolate$3.00
- Maple Whipped CreamHousemade Whipped Cream with Vermont Maple Syrup, Vanilla, and a touch of salt$3.00
505 Myrtle Ave, New York, NY, 11205
