1 / 5

From Sea Shore Restaurant's website

Sea Shore Restaurant

Seafood · New York

By phone

orders & questions

Call to order · (718) 885-0300

Unclaimed listing

Own Sea Shore Restaurant?

We built this page from your own website, so people looking for you can find you. It's yours to take over — here's what that switches on.

Take orders on this pagePickup and delivery, card payments, straight to your kitchen. We take a flat 3% at any volume. Card processing is billed separately by the payment provider, as it is in the dining room — and on a pickup order paid at the counter there isn't any.
Your menu, prices, photos and hoursChange a price at 6pm and it's live at 6pm. Nothing reaches diners until you've confirmed it's right.
An assistant that answers dinersIt knows your menu and your hours, replies day and night, and hands the conversation to you the moment it isn't sure.
Promotions, offers and reservationsRun an offer, take bookings, set a delivery radius — all switched on or off by you.
See who's orderingWhat sells, what gets reordered, and which dishes people ask about but you don't list.

Claim Sea Shore Restaurant — free

Free to claim and free to stay listed. No setup fee, no monthly fee, no card needed. Takes about two minutes.

What to order

from the menu

Traditional New England Split Open Lobster Roll

Served with coleslaw, & french fries

Sea Shore Famous / Towers / Rolls / Platters$42.95

Maryland Lump Crab Cake Dinner

2 large crab cakes

Italian & Pasta Specials$49.95

Twin Lobster Special

Served with a cup of chowder our famous Seashore salad, baked potato or French fries… plus corn bread, garlic bread and our house mountain bread. for the month of June Add a Pina Colada to your meal for just… 14.95 NOT valid on holidays or weekends EXPIRES: last day of June 2026 $42.95 Each No sharing limited availability No takeout AVAILABLE MONDAY THRU FRIDAY

Specials / Twin Lobster$42.95

Select Fried Jumbo Shrimp

a City Island favorite! Always will be!

Fry Chef / Fried Specials$34.95

Sole & Shrimp Special

Our Chef’s Special$49.95

Fish & Chips

Fry Chef / Fried Specials$34.95

Seafood — food to try

3 on this menu

Fish and chips✓ On the menu · $34.95
Beer-battered, fried to order — the batter should shatter.
Here it's “Fish & Chips”.
Crab cakes✓ On the menu · $49.95
Mostly crab, barely bound. Filler is the tell.
Here it's “Maryland Lump Crab Cake Dinner”.
Lobster roll✓ On the menu · $42.95
Cold with mayo or warm with butter; both camps are right.
Here it's “Traditional New England Split Open Lobster Roll”.

Baked Clams Oreganato (1/2 -Doz.)$15.95
Baked Clams Oreganato (1-Doz.)$27.95
Clams Casino a la Sea Shore (8-pieces)$27.95
Littleneck Clams in Garlic or Marinara Sauce$29.95
Fried Calamari$23.95
Pot of Mussels Garlic or Marinara Sauce (hot or sweet)$26.95
Hot Seafood Antipasto for twoFried calamari, scallops, shrimp scampi, baked mussels & 1 piece of King Crab Leg$45.95
Maryland Lump Crabcake$26.95
Coconut Shrimp$29.95
Buffalo Shrimp (spicy)$23.95
Oysters Rockefeller$29.95
Spicy Buffalo Wings$19.95
Half rack of Baby Back Ribs (pork)$22.95
Fried Plattercalamari, buffalo shrimp, bot wings$29.95
Mozzarella Sticks$16.95
Garlic Bread with Cheese$6.95
Lobster & Crab Raviolilobster cream sauce$26.95
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (5-pieces)$25.95
King Crabmeat CocktailDine-in only$34.95
Fresh East Coast (Blue Point) Oysters ($3.95 each)$3.95
Littleneck on the Half Shelf (1/2 doz)$15.95
Littleneck on the Half Shelf (1 dozen)$27.95
Cherrystone on the Half Shelf (1/2 doz)$15.95
Cherrystone on the Half Shelf (1 dozen)$27.95

Soups

Manhattan Clam ChowderDine-in only$9.95
New England Clam Chowder$9.95
Fresh Lobster Bisque$12.95

Our Chef’s Special

Sautes Sole Meuniereserved in a lemon butter and white wine sauce$46.95
Swordfish Samuelserved in a lemon and white wine sauce$49.95
Shrimp Franceseserved in a light lemon and white wine sauce$43.95
Sauteéd Soft Shell Crabs (seasonal)served in a lemon and white wine sauce
Sauteéd Scallops (large sea scallops )$44.95
Sole & Shrimp Special$49.95
Chicken Francese served over linguine$34.95
Jumbo Shrimp Risotto$44.95
Sauteéd Baby Lobster Tailsautéed in lemon & white wine$55.95
Sesame Seared Tunaserved in a soy ginger sauce and Julienne vegetables$49.95
Seafood RisottoLobster, shrimp, baby tails, clams, scallops & mussels$59.95
Tilapia Francesesauteéd in lemon & white wine$42.95
Spicy Seafood Jambalaya New Orleans StyleShrimp, scallops, snow legs & chorizo all served over rice or fresh linguine$55.95
Lobster NewburgMade with 2 lb. losbter in a sherry cream sauce
Shrimp NewburgMade with jumbo shrimp in a sherry cream sauce$47.95
Seafood Newburg1/2 a Maine lobster, shrimp, baby tail, scallops, mussels & clams$64.95

Feasts for two & Paella

Shellfish FeastWhole Maine lobster, shrimp, baby tails, snow crab legs and calms all served steamed or broiled$209.95
Sea Shore Italian FeastA whole Maine lobster, jumbo shrimp, snow crab legs, king crab legs, littleneck clams, mussels, and calamari cooked in a red or garlic sauce and served over a bed of fresh pasta .$209.95
Sea Shore Lobster Feast for two2 lobsters, snow legs, jumbo fried shrimp & baby lobster tails$209.95
Authentic Chicken & Seafood PaellaShrimp, baby tails, snow crab legs, chicken, chorizo (sausage), clams, and mussels, all served over a bed of Spanish yellow rice.$209.95
Barbecue FeastBBQ ribs, BBQ chicken, snow crab legs, and fried jumbo shrimp all served over a bed of Spanish yellow rice$209.95

Surf & Turf / Combos

BBQ Baby Back Ribs & Fried Shrimp$49.95
BBQ Baby Back Ribs & Lobster Tail$49.95
Lobster Tail & Jumbo Fried Shrimp$57.95
Lobster Tail & NY Strip Steak$66.95
Filet Migñon & Lobster Tail$72.95
Filet Migñon & Jumbo Fried Shrimp$62.95
Prime Rib & Lobster Tail$63.95
Shell Steak & Fried Shrimp$58.95
Baby Lobster Tails & Sea Scallops$53.95
Baby Lobster Tails & Jumbo Shrimp$49.95
Baby Lobster Tails, Shrimp & Sea Scallops$59.95

Prime Steaks

Shore Shell Steak (16 oz. Angus Beef)$47.95
Porterhouse Steak (25 oz. Angus Beef)$74.95
T-Bone Steak (22 oz. Angus Beef)$68.95
Filet Migñon (12 oz. Angus Beef)$53.95
Full Rack of BBQ Ribs (pork)$37.95
Prime Rib of Beef$45.95
1/2 Broiled Chicken in a Rosemary Sauce$29.95
BBQ Ribs & Chicken (pork)$36.95
Porter House, Shrimp, Lobster TailFabulous meal, choice out$108.95

Sea Shore Famous / Towers / Rolls / Platters

Montauk Chiller Seafood Tower Two Tier ChillerFabulous Tier of whole Lobster, Shrimp Cocktail, Clams, fresh Oysters, Mussels, Scungilli and Calamari Salad$94.95
Traditional New England Split Open Lobster RollServed with coleslaw, & french fries$42.95
The Tiki Platter Appetizer Platter for 2Spring Rolls, Thai Chili Wings, Pot Stickers, Baby Back Ribs and Coconut Shrimp$42.95
Sea Shore Specials Appetizer Platter for 2Spring Rolls, Thai Chili Wings, Pot Stickers, Baby Back Ribs and Coconut Shrimp$42.95
10 oz. Lobster Tail$49.95
Jumbo Surf & Turf16 oz Steak & 10 oz. Lobster Tail$82.95

Beer (by bottle/draft)Dine-in only

Import Beers$9.00
Domestic Beers$8.00
Draft Beers$8.00

Lobster & Crab / Lobster Dishes

Whole 2 - lb. Maine Lobsterserved steamed or broiled
Whole Maine Lobster 1-1/4 lb.served steamed or broiled
Whole Maine Lobster 1-1/2 lb.served steamed or broiled
Twin Lobster Special (2) 1-1/4lbMaine Lobster served steamed or broiled
Jumbo Lobsters 3, 4, 5, lb. & even largerOnly Maine Lobsters served steamed or broiled
Twin Brazilian (2)$62.95
Baby Lobster Tailsserved scampi style over Spanish yellow rice$55.95
Snow Leg Cluster ( 2 clusters )$68.95
Snow Leg Cluster ( 3 clusters )$89.95
Snow Legs & Fried Shrimp$73.95
Snow Legs & Baby Tails$75.95
Snow Legs & Baby Back Ribs$68.95
Snow Legs & Steak$75.95
Lobster stuffing surchargeAny of the above lobster dishes can be stuffed with our gourmet crabmeat for ..... $24.95$24.95

Salads

Cold Calamari Salad (squid)$23.95
Sea Shore Caesar Salad$14.95
Half Avocado stuffed w/ Crabmeat or Shrimp$29.95
Half Avocado stuffed w/Lobster salad$29.95
Avocado Saladwith iceberg lettuce and grape tomatoes$14.95

Vegetarian & Gluten Free Corner

Gluten Free Pasta w/ Seasonal VegetablesGF$24.95
Grilled Seasonal Vegetables$21.95

Market Catch / Fish

Fillet of Sole$44.95
Whole Flounder ( bone out)$42.95
Salmon Fillet$42.95
Halibut (bone in)$42.95
Swordfish$45.95
Tilapia$41.95
Scrod$41.95
Whole Bronzini$46.95
Stripe Bass$39.95
Tuna$46.95
Whole Red Snapper$53.95

Fry Chef / Fried Specials

Select Fried Jumbo Shrimpa City Island favorite! Always will be!$34.95
Tender Fried Sea Scallopsday boat sea scallops fried to perfection$44.95
Fried Calamariserved w/spicy or mild red sauce$29.95
Tender Scallops & Jumbo Shrimp$49.95
Fried Whole Florida Red Snapper$53.95
Tender Fried Fillet of Sole$42.95
Tender Fried Soft Shell Crabs (seasonal)
Tender Chicken Fingers$29.95
Fish & Chips$34.95
Fried Baby Lobster Tails$58.95
Coconut Fried Shrimp$38.95
Sea Shore Fisherman’s Fried Seafood CombinationJumbo shrimp, scallops, fillet of sole, and tender calamari.$52.95

Italian & Pasta Specials

Linguine w/Mussels in Marinara or Garlic Sauce$34.00
Linguine w/ Littleneck Clams in white or red sauce$34.00
Linguine w/Calamari in marinara sauce (squid)$29.95
Fettuccine Primaverasauteéd vegetables in a light cream sauce$27.95
Fettuccine Alfredo in a cream saucesauteéd vegetables in a light cream sauce$28.95
Lobster Marinara or Fra DiavoloA 2lb. lobster in a marinara sauce over fresh pasta
Linguine LangostinoBaby tails in a garlic wine sauce, light cream sauce or marinara sauce$59.95
Fettuccine ArminioShrimp & scallops in a light creamy lobster sauce$53.95
Shrimp Alfredoin a cream sauce served over fettuccine$44.95
Penne Pasta ala Vodka$27.95
Seafood Marinara or Fra DiavoloLobster, clams, mussels, scallops & shrimp in a choice of garlic, white wine or marinara sauce$62.95
Chicken & Shrimp Parmigiana$42.95
Chicken Parmigiana$28.95
Shrimp Parmigiana$42.95
Shrimp MarinaraShrimp cooked in a fresh tomato marinara sauce$42.95
Maryland Lump Crab Cake Dinner2 large crab cakes$49.95

Fish Specialties

Fillet of Sole Florentinestuffed with spinach in a light cream sauce$46.95
Shrimp Scampi Colossal Selectlarge shrimp gently broiled in butter w/fresh garlic$42.95
Fillet of Sole (stuffed)stuffed with crabmeat or shrimp$59.95
Shrimp Florentineserved over a bed of fresh spinach in a light cream sauce$44.95
Grilled Salmonwild salmon served with fresh spinach and sun-dried tomato vinaigrette$42.95
Shellfish ExtravaganzaA whole lobster, shrimp, giant snow legs, clams & mussels$89.95
Snow Legs, Baby Tails, Shell Steak$79.95
Broiled Sea Scallops & ShrimpA delightful combination broiled to perfection$47.95
Stuffed Jumbo Shrimpdeliciously stuffed with crabmeat$58.95
Caribbean Whole Red Snappersteamed in parchment paper in its natural juices$51.95
Tender Broiled Sea Scallops$44.95
Wood Planked Whole Roasted Red Snappera whole red snapper broiled on cedar wood plank$53.95
BRONZINI Roasted Mediterranian Sea Bassbroiled or cedar wood plank$45.95
Sea Shore Broiled Seafood CombinationFillet, shrimp, scallops,clams,mussels & 1/2 lobster tail$56.95

Sides & Extras

Sauteéd Spinach$6.95
Homemade Potato Croquette$6.95

Frozen & Mixed Drink Specials / Martinis / Smoothies

Try one of these Classic Mojito's your choiceDine-in only$19.95
D'usse or Henney ColadaOur Signature Colada! Hennessy w/pineapple juice, & cream of coconut$23.95
Piña ColadaDine-in onlyBacardi Gold Rum Cream of Coconut & Pineapple Juice$19.95
Strawberry ColadaFresh Strawberries & Strawberry Liqueur$19.95
Banana ColadaBacardi Gold Rum Cream of Coconut & Pineaaple Juice Banana Liqueur & fresh Bananas$19.95
Creamy Piña ColadaDine-in onlyOur famous Colada with Bacardi Light & ice cream$19.95
Frozen MargaritasRegular or Strawberry Margarita$19.95
The Ultimate MargaritaDine-in onlyJose Cuervo 1800 Tequila & Grand Marnier$22.95
Strawberry or Banana Frozen Daquiri's$19.95
Trouble in ParadiseMeyers Rum, Banana Liqueur, Pineapple & Coconut Cream$19.95
Frozen Mudslide or Strawberry SlideIce Cream, Kahlua, Bailey's Irish Cream, & Smirnoff Vodka$19.95
Bahama BreezeBacardi Gold Rum, Amaretto, Pineapple & Coconut Cream$19.95
Frankenstein MonsterA blend of 5-Bacardi rums and then some... Monstrous!$19.95
Tropical PunchA smooth blend of tropical juices with Bacardi Light & Dark Rums$19.95
Sex on the BeachVodka, Peach Schnapps, Orange Juice & Cranberry Juice$19.95
City Island Iced Teaa blend of 5 light liqueurs with a splash of coke and lemon... watch out!$22.95
Tropical Bar & Martinis$19.95
Classic Stoli MartiniDine-in onlyStolichnaya Vodka, shake w/ice, serve w/an olive$19.95
Lemon Drop MartiniDine-in onlyKetel One Citron, a splash of sour mix, in a glass rimmed w/ sugar$19.95
Mango MartiniDine-in onlyMalibu Mango Rum & splash of Rose's Lime$19.95
Key Lime Pie MartiniStolichnaya Vodka, Licor 43, lime juice & a splash of sour mix$19.95
French MartiniDine-in onlyKetel One, Chambord & pineapple juice shaken well & served chilled$19.95
Grand Marnier-tiniGrand Marnier, splash of vodka & pinch of Rose's Lime$19.95
Sex & the CityAlize' Passion & Ketel One w/splash of cranberry$19.95
Black Cherry ChocolateCruzan Black Cherry Rum, White Creme de Cacao & splash of 7-up$19.95
Candy Apple MartiniDine-in onlyBacardi Coco Rum, Pineapple, Bacardi "0, banana liqueur & cranberry juice$19.95
Finlandia MangopolitanFinlandia Mango vodka, triple sec, sour mix, cranberry juice shaken & served$19.95
CosmopolitanDine-in onlyStolichnaya Citrus Vodka, Cointreau, a squeeze of . lime w/cranberry$19.95
HazeltiniKetel One Vodka, Frangelico and Cream$19.95
RazzmopolitanStoli Razz Vodka, Cointreau, a squeeze of lime w/cranberry$19.95
Chocolate MartiniDine-in onlyVan Gogh Chocolate vodka with White Cream de Cacao$19.95
Fresh Fruit SmoothiesBanana • Strawberry • Peach • Mango$8.00

Specials / Twin Lobster

Twin Lobster SpecialServed with a cup of chowder our famous Seashore salad, baked potato or French fries… plus corn bread, garlic bread and our house mountain bread. for the month of June Add a Pina Colada to your meal for just… 14.95 NOT valid on holidays or weekends EXPIRES: last day of June 2026 $42.95 Each No sharing limited availability No takeout AVAILABLE MONDAY THRU FRIDAY$42.95

General / Notices

Complimentary bread & house salad noteDear Patron … enjoy our complimentary fresh baked bread, relish tray and marinated mushrooms before your meal. All entrees come with your choice of Sea Shore House salad consisting of lettuce, baby shrimp, mandarin oranges, tomatoes & croutons. Side dishes include: choice of vegetables, baked potato, french fries, rice, pasta garlic or marinara sauce or onion rings. Enjoy your meal. (Plate charge for sharing is $8.00 includes: salad, vegetables & side dish).

591 City Island Ave, New York, NY, 10464

Directions

Website ↗