Gage and Tollner
★ 4.3 (1,389) ›Brooklyn
By phone
orders & questions
AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies
try the Signature Coconut Cake
Charming American restaurant, serving steak, chops, oysters and seafood dishes.
What people mention: Beautiful, historic, old‑world dining room with standout cocktails and appetizers, and many reviewers praising the classic atmosphere and well-executed starters.(from 5 recent reviews)
Description from Google
What to order
from the menuSignature Coconut Cake
A large format version of our signature menu item. Fluffy coconut lime cake layered with coconut pastry cream and fresh lime curd. Finished with coconut Swiss meringue buttercream, cashew pink peppercorn brittle, fresh flowers and toasted coconut. Can be made nut-free.
Celebration Cakes
Carrot Cake
Walnut carrot cake with coconut and a classic cream cheese frosting. No raisins! Decorated with walnuts and toasted coconut.
Celebration Cakes
Lemon Poppy Olive Oil
Supple lemon poppy olive oil cake layers, filled with fresh lemon curd, and finished with Swiss meringue buttercream. Decorated with candied lemon zest and fresh flowers. Nut free.
Celebration Cakes
8” (serves 12-16)
Cake Sizes / Prices$145
10” (serves up to 20)
Cake Sizes / Prices$190
372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY, 11201-5104
HoursAll hours ▾Hide ▴
- Monday
- 5pm–6pm
- Tuesday
- 5pm–6pm
- Wednesday
- 5pm–6pm
- Thursday
- 5pm–6pm
- Friday
- 5pm–6pm
- Saturday
- Closed
- Sunday
- 3pm–5pm
Hours from the restaurant's website — call ahead on holidays.
Popular restaurants nearby
New York
FeaturedKatz's Deli
Sandwiches
4.5★ (55,000+)·$$

Ellen's Cafe
Cafe
4.4★ (24,500+)·1.9 mi

Ivan Ramen
Japanese
4.7★ (10,000+)·2.0 mi

Prince Street Pizza
New York
4.4★ (9,000+)·2.2 mi

Lombardi's
Pizza
4.2★ (9,000+)·2.1 mi

Rubirosa
Italian
4.7★ (7,500+)·2.2 mi

Nom Wah Tea Parlor
Dim sum
4.2★ (5,000+)·1.7 mi

Xi'an Famous Foods - SOHO
Chinese
4.5★ (2,000+)·1.6 mi

Denny's
Breakfast
4.2★ (2,000+)·1.7 mi
More in New Yorkbrowse the whole city →