Prince Street Pizza
New York
By phone
orders & questions
What to order
from the menuBURGER PIE
Seasoned ground beef ,melty new school american cheese ,dill pickles,and super-special sauce.
House Favorites$48
Smoked Mutz
Made with homemade fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.
Pizza$36.40
Broadway Breadcrumb (No Mutz)
Cut onion (secret homemade marinara sauce, breadcrumbs on pecorino romano cheese). The option can be a vegan pie also if you select the option below!
Pizza$36.50
napolitana (Pepperoni Pie)
(Secret homemade spicy sauce, with curly cuts pepperoni and fresh mozzarella)
Pizza$31
Prince St Veggie Pie
Made with homemade fresh tomato sauce, mix vegetables. (Green peppers, tomatoes, red onion, mushrooms, black olives)
Neapolitan Style Pizzas (Round)$39.98
The Fancy Prince (Margherita Pie)
Homemade tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil
Neapolitan Style Pizzas (Round)$36.40
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-02Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
House Favorites
- Mercer Margarita (Grandma Style)Made with fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella and basil.$38.50
- Buzzy Broome VodkaDine-in onlyMade with homemade fresh vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella & pecorino romano cheese.$36.40
- The Original PrinceClassic round pie. Made with fresh homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella.$26.84
- BURGER PIESeasoned ground beef ,melty new school american cheese ,dill pickles,and super-special sauce.$48.00
- Green Machine (Pesto Pie)Pesto sauce, mozzarella, ricotta and extra virgin olive oil. Also, black olives$38.40
- Spicy Spring™Fra diavolo sauce, spicy pepperoni and fresh mozzarella.$47.84
- Italian Rainbow Cake7 layered almond-flavored Italian-American cookie cake with a raspberry filling$8.00
- NY Cheesecake (actually made in NY)Creamy cheesecake with a Graham cracker crust$8.00
- Flourless Chocolate CakeSemi-sweet chocolate melted with butter and eggs, baked to perfection$8.00
Pizza
- The Fancy Prince (Margherita Pie)A must-try house specialty!$36.40
- Mercer Margarita (Grandma Style)Made with fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella and basil.$38.50
- Buzzy Broome VodkaDine-in onlyMade with homemade fresh vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella & pecorino romano cheese.$36.40
- Green Machine (Pesto Pie)Pesto sauce, mozzarella, ricotta and extra virgin olive oil. Also, black olives.$38.40
- Smoked MutzMade with homemade fresh tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, and fresh basil.$36.40
- Meat Lover SquareSausage + Pepperoni$53.85
- Broadway Breadcrumb (No Mutz)Cut onion (secret homemade marinara sauce, breadcrumbs on pecorino romano cheese). The option can be a vegan pie also if you select the option below!$36.50
- napolitana (Pepperoni Pie)(Secret homemade spicy sauce, with curly cuts pepperoni and fresh mozzarella)$31.00
- The Original PrinceClassic round pie. Made with fresh homemade tomato sauce and mozzarella.$26.84
- Gluten free pizzagluten free pizza any sauce of you choice$25.00
- BURGER PIESeasoned ground beef ,melty new school american cheese ,dill pickles,and super-special sauce.$48.00
Neapolitan Style Pizzas (Round)
- Smoked MutzSmoke mozzarella, basil, and pecorino Romano$38.38
- Prince St Veggie PieMade with homemade fresh tomato sauce, mix vegetables. (Green peppers, tomatoes, red onion, mushrooms, black olives)$39.98
- The Original PrinceClassic round pie. Marinara sauce & grated mozzarella.$26.84
- The Fancy Prince (Margherita Pie)Homemade tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil$36.40
- Green Machine (Pesto Pie)Pesto sauce, mozzarella, ricotta and extra virgin olive oil. Also, black olives$38.40
- Buzzy Broome VodkaDine-in onlyMade with homemade fresh vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella & pecorino romano cheese.$36.40
The Original Soho Squares
- Houston JalapenoSpicy Pepperoni + Jalapeno + Hot honey$47.84
- Mercer Margherita (Grandma Style)Fresh mozzarella, basil, fresh garlic, and extra virgin olive oil, also pecorino romano$38.50
- Vodka Fra Diavolo Square PieMade with homemade fresh Fra Diavolo spicy sauce mixed with homemade traditional vodka sauce.$47.84
- 4 Cheese SquareSeasoned breadcrumbs, secret marinara sauce, pecorino romano and extra virgin olive oil (cheese-less pizza). Option to make it vegan if you select below!$53.85
- Spicy Spring™Fra diavolo sauce, spicy pepperoni and fresh mozzarella.$47.84
- Gluten free pizza spicy spring ( pepperoni cups )$25.00
- Gluten free pizza Prince Perfection$25.00
- Gluten free pizza 4 cheese pie$25.00
- Gluten free pizza vodka fry Diablo$25.00
- Prince Perfection™(Secret) homemade marinara sauce, with pecorino romano cheese, and extra virgin olive oil.$41.02
- Gluten free pizza meat lover$25.00
- Gluten free pizza naughty pie$25.00
- Naughty PieSpicy Vodka Sauce, Pepperoni Cups, Impastata Ricotta, Hot Honey$53.85
Special
- Italian Rainbow Cake7 layered almond-flavored Italian-American cookie cake with a raspberry filling$8.00
- NY Cheesecake (actually made in NY)Creamy cheesecake with a Graham cracker crust$8.00
- Flourless Chocolate CakeSemi-sweet chocolate melted with butter and eggs, baked to perfection$8.00
Sides of Sauce
- House Marinara SauceSecret house tomatoes with basil.$2.00
- Spicy SauceHot and spicy!$2.00
- Vodka SauceProsciutto, cream, tomatoes & vodka$2.00
Beverages
- WaterBottled water.$2.50
- SodaNothing like a cold soda to wash down your pizza.$2.50
- Red Bull$4.00
27 Prince St, New York, NY, 10012
