1 / 4
From Godfather Pizza's website

From Godfather Pizza's website

Godfather Pizza

Pizza · New York

By phone

orders & questions

Call to order · (845) 565-2244

What to order

from the menu

Menu

from the website · 2026-09-02

Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.

Appetizer

  • Fried CalamariCrispy calamari with arugula and a grilled lemon vinagrette$16.00
  • Fried RavioliSpinach and Ricotta-Filled Ravioli, Scallion Cream Sauce$14.00
  • Organic Caesar SaladRomaine Lettuce, Asiago Croutons, Homemade Caesar Dressing$14.00
  • Organic Sherry Tomato SoupSherry Whine, House made Croutons$12.00
  • Bruschetta ClassicoPlum Tomatoes, Sweet Basil, Garlic, Fresh Homemade Mozzarella, Balsamic Glaze$12.00
  • Antipasto SicilianoImported mortadella, prosciutto, prosciutto cotto and genoa salami with fresh mozzarella, marinated artichokes and kalamata olives.$18.00
  • EscargotSnails battered in a creamy butter sauce fresh garlic, Romaine lettuce$18.00

Entrées

  • Spicy Shrimp & Lobster PastaClassic Italian seafood dish with a twist shrimp and lobster cooked served in a creamy sauce with capellini$30.00
  • Mild ★ Jerk Shrimp PastaSeafood and Caribbean taste combined served with linguine *chef special*$40.00
  • Tapas PastaRigatoni Pasta with chunks of smoky chorizo sausage, garlicky shrimp, sweet roasted peppers, briny olives$30.00
  • Eggplant ParmesanBaked eggplant with a fresh tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese$32.00
  • Chicken MarsalaOrganic chicken with sauteed mushrooms and truffle cooked in a creamy garlic sauce$38.00
  • Organic Chicken FrancaiseSauteed chicken cutlets cooked in a fresh lemon butter and white wine sauce$32.00

Desserts

  • Italian CheesecakeFresh ricotta and cream cheese blended with assorted nuts$15.00
  • American CheesecakeClassic cheesecake with fresh whip cream, chocolate drizzle and strawberries on the side$17.00
  • Chocolate MousseCreamy dark chocolate with raspberries and whipped cream for garnish$16.00
  • TiramisuEspresso blend with dark chocolate, a creamy liqueur filling and chocolate truffles as garnish$18.00
  • Fruit MixApple, pear, pineapple, and kiwi sliced in a bowl with sweet crushed nuts and liquid nitrogen$25.00
  • Classic Fudge SundaeVanilla bean ice cream with white truffle, gold flakes, and caramel drizzle on top$65.00

75 9th Ave, New York, NY, 10011-4730

Directions
Website

Similar places nearby

New York