Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery
Bakery · New York
By phone
orders & questions
What to order
from the menuOreo Cookie
Oreo cupcake with cream cheese
Cupcakes$3.75
Mini Cupcakes
Mini cupcakes 1 dozen per cake flavor. Allow 48 hours.
Mini Cupcakes$24
4" Double Layer
All layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request
Layer Cakes$25
7” Double Layer
All layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request
Layer Cakes$45
9” Double Layer
All layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request
Layer Cakes$60
Vegan Cookies (per dozen)
Please allow 24 hour notice. 1 dozen per flavor.
Vegan Cookies$18
Bakery — food to try
1 on this menuCookie✓ On the menu · $3.75
The chocolate chip cookie tells you if they respect butter.
Here it's “Oreo Cookie”.
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-01Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Cupcakes
- SunshineYellow cake with vanilla buttercream$3.75
- BobYellow cake with chocolate almond buttercream$3.75
- Ooey GooeyChocolate cake with chocolate almond buttercream$3.75
- Sexy Red VelvetRed velvet cake with a satin swiss buttercream$3.75
- Sassy Red VelvetRed velvet cake with chocolate almond buttercream$3.75
- Black & White…Just RightChocolate cake with vanilla buttercream$3.75
- PistachioPistachio cake with a satin swiss buttercream$3.75
- PumpkinPumpkin cake with cream cheese icing$3.75
- Lemon YummyLemon cake with lemon buttercream$3.75
- Faux - CoconutCoconut cake with vanilla buttercream$3.75
- StrawberryStrawberry cake with cream cheese$3.75
- Oreo CookieOreo cupcake with cream cheese$3.75
- German ImposterDark chocolate cake topped with pecans & coconut$3.75
Mini Cupcakes
- Mini CupcakesMini cupcakes 1 dozen per cake flavor. Allow 48 hours.$24.00
Vegan Cupcakes
- Vegan Cupcakes (per cupcake)vegan$3.75
- Vegan Cupcakes (per dozen)vegan$45.00
- Vegan Sunshine CupcakeveganYellow cake with vanilla buttercream | 100% vegan$3.75
- Vegan Black & WhiteveganChocolate cake with vanilla buttercream | 100% vegan
- Vegan Chocolate ExplosionveganVegan chocolate cake with vegan chocolate buttercream. So decadent | 100% vegan
- Vegan French ToastveganVanilla cupcake with cinnamon and nutmeg spiced vanilla buttercream | 100% vegan
Layer Cakes
- 4" Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$25.00
- 7” Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$45.00
- 9” Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$60.00
- 7” Triple LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$50.00
- 9” Triple LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$70.00
- 10" Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$84.00
- 12” Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$120.00
- 9” x 12” Quarter Single LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$60.00
- 12” x 18” Single Layer Sheet CakeAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$120.00
- 18” x 24” Full SheetAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$245.00
- 14” Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$170.00
- 16” Double LayerAll layer cakes can be matched with the icing of your choice Fillings available upon request$245.00
Icings
- Vanilla Buttercream
- Chocolate Almond Buttercream
- Chocolate Buttercream
- Satin Buttercream
- Lemon Buttercream
- Cream Cheese
- German Chocolate
- Coconut and Pecans
Puddings
- Shot$5.00
- 10 oz.$7.50
- 16 oz.$9.75
- 64 oz. Tub$45.00
- Banana Puddin’
- Chocolate Chip Deliciousness
- Chocolate Bomb
- Awesome Peanut Butter Chocolate Puddin’
- The Coffee Java Xpress
- Sexy Red Velvet Puddin’
- The Nog
- Strawberry Lemon Trifle
Not Layer Cakes
- Not Layer Cakes (per slice)$5.00
- Not Layer Cakes (whole)$48.00
- Pistachio Bundt
- Marble Bundt
- Lemon Bundt
- Inescapeable Apple Cake “The Real Deal” Coffee Cake
- Vegan Chocolate Bundtvegan
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
- Pineapple Upside Down Cake (whole)$45.00
Pies
- 9" fruit pies$35.00
- 4-1/2" pie$6.50
- 9" cream pies$40.00
- Cream Pie$7.00
- Apple
- Strawberry
- Rhubarb
- Pecan
- Pumpkin
- Blueberry
- Crispy Crumble
- Coconut Cream Pie
- Peanut Butter Ice Box
Sugar Sweet Specialties
- 7” Double Layer Strawberry Shortcake$63.00
- 9” Double Layer Strawberry Shortcake$78.00
- Tres Leche with RumDine-in only$8.50
- Flan (per slice)$7.00
- Flan (9" x 13")$75.00
- New York Cheesecake (per serving)$7.00
- New York Cheesecake (whole)$68.00
Bars
- Oooh…Brownies$5.50
- Yum-Yum BarShortbread crust layered with raspberry, semi sweet chocolate chips and a walnut crumble.$6.00
- Gluten Free BrownieGF$6.50
- Espresso Brownie
- Vegan Chocolate Brownievegan100% Vegan & Dairy Free$6.00
Drinks
- Hot Coffee
- Tea
- Cappucino
- Latte
- Caffe au Lait
- Chai Latte
- Red Eye
- Mocha
- Hot Chocolate
- Apple CiderDine-in only
- Espresso
- Fresh Hibiscus Tea
- Iced Coffee
- Iced Latte
- Iced Cappucino
- Iced Chai Latte
- Iced Apple CiderDine-in only
- Iced Mocha
- Iced Americano
- Water Bottle
- Canned Soda
365 Grand St, New York, NY, 10002
