Third Rail Coffee
Cafe · New York
By phone
orders & questions
What to order
from the menuCafe — food to try
2 on this menuEspresso✓ On the menu · $3.75
A straight shot is the fastest read on the roaster and the barista.
Cortado✓ On the menu · $4.25
Equal parts espresso and steamed milk — small, strong, balanced.
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-02Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Espresso & Short Drinks
- EspressoOur everyday espresso is a custom blend roasted for us by our friends at the Pulley Collective in Red Hook.$3.75
- AmericanoSweet espresso in hot water.$4.25
- MacchiattoEspresso 'marked' by foam. Ours is a 3oz. beauty, 2/3rds espresso, 1/3rd velvety micro-foamed milk.$4.25
- CortadoMaybe our favorite drink. Half espresso, half steamed milk - full on delicious.$4.25
Milk-based Espresso Drinks
- CappuccinoEspresso and steamed milk with a dense layer of micro-foam atop. Default size is 6oz total (to stay) or closer to 8oz. (to go).$4.75
- LatteEspresso and silky smooth steamed milk. Available in 8 and 12oz sizes. Add our homemade Vanilla for an additional charge$4.75
- MochaA latte bolstered by sweet sweet chocolate! Ours is a single-origin cocoa from Ghana.$5.75
- Iced LatteDecadent summer-time fave. Espresso and sweet Battenkill Dairy Farm milk over ice. Make it a mocha for just 50¢ more and prepare to swoon. One size.$5.50
Coffee & Tea
- Drip CoffeeCurrently a custom blend roasted for us by the Pulley Collective in Red Hook. Available in 8/12/16 oz.$2.90
- Hot TeaPremium loose leaf teas from Rishi - choose from Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Dragonwell (green), or Chamomille Medley$4.00
- Chai LatteMade with Dona Chai...chai...$4.50
- Cold-brewed Iced CoffeeBrewed in house a full 24 hours for an unusually smooth and refreshing "chuggable" iced coffee. Available year round.$5.00
- Iced TeaWe brew up fresh batches of a "Classic" blend of black teas. Unsweetened.$4.00
- Hot CocoaFreshly steamed Battenkill Dairy Farms milk and Omanhene cocoa combine for a perfect winter treat.$4.00
Baked Goods
- Croissantsbaked by Bien Cuit - Butter, Chocolate, Almond, Ham&Cheese$4.50
- Muffins$4.25
- Cookies$3.75
159 2nd Ave, New York, NY, 10003






