Utopia Bagels
Bagels · New York
By phone
orders & questions
Unclaimed listing
Own Utopia Bagels?
We built this page from your own website, so people looking for you can find you. It's yours to take over — here's what that switches on.
- Take orders on this pagePickup and delivery, card payments, straight to your kitchen. We take a flat 3% at any volume. Card processing is billed separately by the payment provider, as it is in the dining room — and on a pickup order paid at the counter there isn't any.
- Your menu, prices, photos and hoursChange a price at 6pm and it's live at 6pm. Nothing reaches diners until you've confirmed it's right.
- An assistant that answers dinersIt knows your menu and your hours, replies day and night, and hands the conversation to you the moment it isn't sure.
- Promotions, offers and reservationsRun an offer, take bookings, set a delivery radius — all switched on or off by you.
- See who's orderingWhat sells, what gets reordered, and which dishes people ask about but you don't list.
Free to claim and free to stay listed. No setup fee, no monthly fee, no card needed. Takes about two minutes.
What to order
from the menuNova Bagel
Cream Cheese$7.80
Everything
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Standard$2
The Queen
Everything seed nova, scallion CC, lettuce, cucumber & olive oil
Nova Sandwiches$17.95
The Lex
Pastrami nova, jalapeño, red onion & mustard
Nova Sandwiches$16.95
The Scotty
Nova, white fish salad, tomato, red onion & capers
Nova Sandwiches$19.25
The Freak
Bacon, egg, cheddar, hashbrown, jalapeño & hot sauce
Egg Sandwiches$10.75
Bagels — food to try
2 on this menuEverything bagel✓ On the menu · $2
Boiled then baked, with a chewy crust — the test of a real bagel.
Here it's “Everything”.
Lox and cream cheese✓ On the menu · $7.80
Cured salmon, capers, red onion. The classic order.
Here it's “Nova Bagel”.
Bacon egg and cheeseask if they make it
The breakfast sandwich, on a bagel. Ask for it toasted.
Menu
from the website · 2026-09-02Prices and items may have changed. Display only — this restaurant isn't taking orders here yet.
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Standard
- Plain$2.00
- Cinnamon Raisin$2.00
- French Toast$2.00
- Whole Wheat$2.00
- Salt$2.00
- Pumpernickel$2.00
- Everything$2.00
- Blueberry$2.00
- Egg Everything$2.00
- Whole Wheat Everything$2.00
- Onion$2.00
- Everything Bialy$2.00
- Sesame$2.00
- Poppy$2.00
- Egg$2.00
- Rye$2.00
- Garlic$2.00
- Bialy$2.00
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Specialty Flavors
- Asiago$3.00
- Multi-Grain$3.00
- Piña ColadaDine-in only$3.00
- Flat Sesame$3.00
- Jalapeño Cheddar$3.00
- Sourdough$3.00
- Flat Everything$3.00
- Flat Poppy$3.00
- Rainbow$3.00
- Low Carb$3.00
- Flat Plain$3.00
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Gluten Free
- Gluten Free PlainGF$4.00
- Gluten Free EverythingGF$4.00
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Mini Bagels
- Mini Bagels Plain$1.25
- Mini Bagels Poppy$1.25
- Mini Bagels Rye$1.25
- Mini Bagels Sesame$1.25
- Mini Bagels Cinnamon Raisin$1.25
- Mini Bagels Pumpernickel$1.25
- Mini Bagels Everything$1.25
- Mini Bagels Whole Wheat$1.25
- Mini Bagels Bialy$1.25
Bagels, Schmears & Fish - Baker's Dozen
- Baker's DozenStarting At$24.00
Cream Cheese
- Plain Bagel$4.50
- Scallion Bagel$4.95
- Vegetable Bagel$4.95
- Cinnamon Apple Bagel$4.95
- Walnut Raisin Bagel$4.95
- Jalapeño Bagel$4.95
- Olive Bagel$4.95
- Strawberry Bagel$4.95
- Blueberry Bagel$4.95
- Oreo Bagel$4.95
- Birthday Cake Bagel$4.95
- Bacon Bagel$5.50
- Nova Bagel$7.80
Low Fat Cream Cheese
- Low Fat Plain Bagel$5.50
- Low Fat Scallion Bagel$5.95
- Low Fat Vegetable Bagel$5.95
Tofu Cream Cheese
- Tofu Plain Bagel$5.50
- Tofu Scallion Bagel$5.95
- Tofu Vegetable Bagel$5.95
- Tofu Strawberry Bagel$5.95
- Tofu Blueberry Bagel$5.95
Butter or Jelly / PB / Nutella
- Butter or Jelly Bagel$3.50
- PB or Nutella Bagel$5.50
Deli Salads
- Egg Salad Bagel$6.50
- Egg Salad 1/2 lb$6.00
- Tuna Salad Bagel$8.25
- Tuna Salad 1/2 lb$9.50
- Chicken Salad Bagel$8.25
- Chicken Salad 1/2 lb$9.50
- Country Chicken Bagel$8.75
- Country Chicken 1/2 lb$10.00
- Chipotle Chicken Bagel$8.75
- Chipotle Chicken 1/2 lb$10.00
- White Fish Salad Bagel$11.25
- White Fish Salad 1/2 lb$12.50
- Baked Salmon Bagel$12.50
- Baked Salmon 1/2 lb$14.00
- Shrimp Salad Bagel$11.25
- Shrimp Salad 1/2 lb$12.50
- Lobster Salad Bagel$12.50
- Lobster Salad 1/2 lb$14.00
- Chopped Herring Bagel$10.75
- Chopped Herring 1/2 lb$12.00
- Macaroni Salad 1/2 lb$4.50
- Potato Salad 1/2 lb$4.50
- Coleslaw 1/2 lb$4.50
Sliced Nova / Fish
- Nova 1/2 lb$29.00
- Belly Nova 1/2 lb$30.00
- Pastrami Nova 1/2 lb$30.00
- Everything Seed 1/2 lb$30.00
- Whole White Fish 1/2 lb$16.00
- Sturgeon 1/2 lb$34.00
- Baked Salmon 1/2 lb (Fish)$28.00
- Sable 1/2 lb$32.00
- Herring & Cream Sauce 1/2 lb$14.00
Breakfast - Egg Platters & Omelettes
- Build Your Own Omelette or Platter$9.25
- Spinach Feta Egg White$12.25
- WesternHam, cheddar, pepper & onion$12.25
- Garden VeggieTomato, spinach, pepper & onion$12.25
- Nova & Onion$14.25
- Meat LoversSausage, bacon, ham, egg & mozzarella$14.25
- Hungry Man PlatterChoice of egg, meat & cheese$12.25
- Frankenstein PlatterChoice of egg, meat & cheese, 1 pancake, 1 french toast$17.25
Nova Sandwiches
- Build Your Own Nova SandwichStarts with nova & plain CC$15.25
- The QueenEverything seed nova, scallion CC, lettuce, cucumber & olive oil$17.95
- The LexPastrami nova, jalapeño, red onion & mustard$16.95
- The ScottyNova, white fish salad, tomato, red onion & capers$19.25
- The Worth ItCC, tomato, red onion & capers$16.75
Egg Sandwiches
- Build Your Own Egg SandwichStarts with 2 eggs any style$5.25
- Baconeggandcheese$8.25
- Sausageeggandcheese$8.25
- The HoboTaylor ham, egg, cheese & home fries$10.25
- Healthy WrapTurkey, egg white & Swiss$9.75
- Upside Down Grilled CheeseChoice of meat & cheese$8.75
- The FreakBacon, egg, cheddar, hashbrown, jalapeño & hot sauce$10.75
- The CheechSausage, egg, cheese, hashbrown & avocado$10.75
- L.E.S.Pastrami, fried egg & Swiss$11.25
- Tio's Bkfast BurritoChorizo, egg, pepper jack, hashbrown, pepper & onion$12.95
Sides
- Home Fries$6.00
- Hashbrown$2.00
Lunch - Sandwiches
- Build Your Own Lunch Sandwich$9.25
- B.L.T.$8.75
- Lobster Salad B.L.T.$15.25
- Chicken TimeChicken salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato$11.25
- Country Chicken TimeChicken salad with cranberries, walnuts, lettuce & tomato$11.25
- Buffalo BillBuffalo chicken, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato & chipotle mayo$12.25
- Chicken GrillerGrilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, avocado & honey mustard$12.25
- CowboyChicken cutlet, bacon, cheese & BBQ sauce$12.25
- The AdonisChicken cutlet, muenster, bacon, lettuce, mayo & hot sauce$12.25
- Citi FielderCracked peppermill turkey, muenster, avocado, lettuce, tomato & mayo$12.25
- Yankee ClipperChicken cutlet, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, sundried tomatoes & mayo$12.25
- HawaiianHam, Swiss, avocado & chipotle mayo$12.25
- Honey BeeHoney turkey, bacon, muenster & honey mustard$12.25
- Tex MexChipotle chicken, bacon, pepper jack & chipotle mayo$12.25
- Jamaican Jerkchicken, pepper jack, lettuce, tomato, avocado & chipotle mayo$12.25
- Black ForestBlack forest ham, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato & mayo$12.25
- Smokey & the BaconTurkey, bacon, cheddar & pickles$12.25
- Angry BirdGrilled chicken, bacon, provolone, tomato & chipotle mayo$12.25
- CubanoRoast pork, ham, Swiss, pickles & chipotle mayo$13.25
- Texas MeltRoast beef, bacon & mozzarella$13.25
- Cordon BleuChicken cutlet, ham, bacon, Swiss & mayo$13.25
- The DudeChicken cutlet, roast beef, bacon, white American, lettuce, tomato & mayo$13.25
- The Big TRoast beef, turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato & onion$13.25
- Philly SteakSteak, provolone, pepper & onion$13.25
- New YorkerPastrami, Swiss, coleslaw & mustard$13.25
- The UtopiaProsciutto, mozzarella, lettuce, roasted peppers, olive oil & vinegar$13.25
- Italian StallionSoppressata, capicola, prosciutto, provolone, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, olive oil & vinegar$13.25
- She's So ParmChicken cutlet, prosciutto, mozzarella & spicy vodka sauce$15.25
Coffee & Tea - Hot
- Hot Regular Small$3.00
- Hot Regular Large$4.00
- Decaf Small$3.00
- Decaf Large$4.00
- French Vanilla Small$3.00
- French Vanilla Large$4.00
- Hazelnut Small$3.00
- Hazelnut Large$4.00
- Specialty Hot Chocolate Small$3.25
- Specialty Hot Chocolate Large$4.50
- French Vanilla Hot Chocolate Small$3.00
- French Vanilla Hot Chocolate Large$4.00
- Cappuccino Hot Chocolate Small$3.25
- Cappuccino Hot Chocolate Large$4.50
- Tea Small$3.00
- Tea Large$4.00
Coffee & Tea - Cold
- Iced Coffee Small$3.75
- Iced Coffee Large$4.75
- Iced Decaf Small$3.75
- Iced Decaf Large$4.75
- Iced French Vanilla Small$3.75
- Iced French Vanilla Large$4.75
- Iced Hazelnut Small$3.75
- Iced Hazelnut Large$4.75
Milk Options
- French Vanilla Creamer$0.50
- Hazelnut Creamer$0.50
- Caramel Creamer$0.50
- Almond Milk$1.00
- Oat Milk$1.00
Waffles, Pancakes & French Toast - Waffles
- Waffles$11.25
- Waffles Fruit$12.25
- Nutella Strawberry Waffle$13.95
Waffles, Pancakes & French Toast - Pancakes
- Pancakes$11.25
- Blueberry or chocolate chip Pancakes$12.25
- S&S PancakesBacon, banana, and chocolate chips$13.95
- Reese's PancakesPeanut butter chips topped with Nutella$13.95
Waffles, Pancakes & French Toast - French Toast
- French Toast$11.25
- French Toast Fruit$12.25
- Peanut Butter Banana French Toast$13.95
- Nutella Strawberry French Toast$13.95
Party Style Bagel Wheels
- Chicken Cutlet SupremeChicken cutlet, muenster, lettuce & tomato$275.00
- Italian SupremeProsciutto, capicola, soppressata, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato & roasted peppers$275.00
- American SupremeHam, turkey, Swiss, lettuce & tomato$275.00
- Giant Baconeggandcheese$225.00
- The Worth ItNova, CC, tomato, red onion & capers$350.00
- Pizza Bagel$100.00
- Additional Flavors - Pepperoni$20.00
- Additional Flavors - Chicken Parm$20.00
- Additional Flavors - Sausage and Peppers$20.00
120 E 34th St, New York, NY, 10016-0038
