From Scarr's Pizza's website

Scarr's Pizza

★ 4.3 (4,907) ›Pizza · New York

Open

closes 11pm

By phone

orders & questions

Call to order · (212) 334-3481

Feeding a crowd? Ask Scarr's Pizza to quote for an event.

I ate here Add to my list

A stop onThe NYC slice crawl

AI concierge· knows this menu, plans for a group, minds your allergies

Open · closes 11pm · try the Vegan Garlic Knots · about $28 a person

Busy joint serving thin-crust and square slices, plus pies.

What people mention: Reviewers consistently mention hot, fresh pizza slices featuring high-quality ingredients, a classic busy NYC slice-shop atmosphere, and generally good service with occasional short waits.(from 5 recent reviews)

Description from Google

What to order

from the menu

Vegan Garlic Knots

Served with Side of Sauce 3 Pieces

Appetizers / Starters$8

Margherita 12"

Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Basil, EVOO

12" Specialty Pies$28

Hotboi 12"

Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, Cheese, Ezzo’s Beef Pepperoni, Jalapeños, Mike’s Extra Hot Honey

12" Specialty Pies$34

Vegan 12"

Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Basil, EVOO

12" Specialty Pies$28

Cheese Calzone

Caputo Brothers Fresh Mozz, Served with Side of Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce

Calzones$22

Vegan Cheese Calzone

Organic DiNapoli Tomato Sauce, NUMU Vegan Cheese, Fresh Garlic, Roasted Red Peppers, Basil

Calzones$24

Pizza — food to try

2 on this menu

Cheese pizza✓ On the menu · $36
The plainest pie is the honest test of the crust and sauce.
Here it's “Margherita Pie”.
Garlic knots✓ On the menu · $8
Same dough, tied and buttered — the side to share while you wait.
Here it's “Vegan Garlic Knots”.